Fetcko Kaleigh, Lukas Rimas V, Watson Gordon A, Zhang Lingjiao, Dey Mahua
Department of Neurosurgery, Indiana University, Indianapolis, IN Department of Biostatistics and Epidemiology, University of Pennsylvania Perelman School of Medicine, Philidelphia, PA Department of Neurology, Northwestern University, Chicago, IL Department of Radiation Oncology, Simon Cancer Center, Indiana University, Indianapolis, IN.
Medicine (Baltimore). 2017 Oct;96(43):e8293. doi: 10.1097/MD.0000000000008293.
Utilization of stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) for treatment of high-grade gliomas (HGGs) has been slowly increasing with variable reported success rates.
Systematic review of the available data to evaluate the efficacy of SRS as a treatment for HGG with regards to median overall survival (OS) and progression-free survival (PFS), in addition to ascertaining the rate of radiation necrosis and other SRS-related major neurological complications.
Literature searches were performed for publications from 1992 to 2016. The pooled estimates of median PFS and median OS were calculated as a weighted estimate of population medians. Meta-analyses of published rates of radiation necrosis and other major neurological complications were also performed.
Twenty-nine studies reported the use of SRS for recurrent HGG, and 16 studies reported the use of SRS for newly diagnosed HGG. For recurrent HGG, the pooled estimates of median PFS and median OS were 5.42 months (3-16 months) and 20.19 months (9-65 months), respectively; the pooled radiation necrosis rate was 5.9% (0-44%); and the pooled estimates of major neurological complications rate was 3.3% (0-23%). For newly diagnosed HGG, the pooled estimates of median PFS and median OS were 7.89 months (5.5-11 months) and 16.87 months (9.5-33 months) respectively; the pooled radiation necrosis rate was 6.5% (0-33%); and the pooled estimates of other major neurological complications rate was 1.5% (0-25%).
Our results suggest that SRS holds promise as a relatively safe treatment option for HGG. In terms of efficacy at this time, there are inadequate data to support routine utilization of SRS as the standard of care for newly diagnosed or recurrent HGG. Further studies should be pursued to define more clearly the therapeutic role of SRS.
立体定向放射外科(SRS)用于治疗高级别胶质瘤(HGG)的应用一直在缓慢增加,报道的成功率各不相同。
系统回顾现有数据,以评估SRS作为HGG治疗方法在中位总生存期(OS)和无进展生存期(PFS)方面的疗效,此外还要确定放射性坏死率和其他与SRS相关的主要神经并发症发生率。
检索1992年至2016年的出版物。中位PFS和中位OS的合并估计值计算为总体中位数的加权估计值。还对已发表的放射性坏死率和其他主要神经并发症发生率进行了荟萃分析。
29项研究报告了SRS用于复发性HGG的情况,16项研究报告了SRS用于新诊断的HGG的情况。对于复发性HGG,中位PFS和中位OS的合并估计值分别为5.42个月(3 - 16个月)和20.19个月(9 - 65个月);合并放射性坏死率为5.9%(0 - 44%);主要神经并发症发生率的合并估计值为3.3%(0 - 23%)。对于新诊断的HGG,中位PFS和中位OS的合并估计值分别为7.89个月(5.5 - 11个月)和16.87个月(9.5 - 33个月);合并放射性坏死率为6.5%(0 - 33%);其他主要神经并发症发生率的合并估计值为1.5%(0 - 25%)。
我们的结果表明,SRS有望成为HGG相对安全的治疗选择。就目前的疗效而言,尚无足够数据支持将SRS常规用作新诊断或复发性HGG的标准治疗方法。应进一步开展研究以更明确地界定SRS的治疗作用。