Foulds Hayley
Department of Paediatric Dentistry, Glasgow Dental Hospital and School & the Royal Hospital for Children, Glasgow, Scotland.
Evid Based Dent. 2017 Oct 27;18(3):72-73. doi: 10.1038/sj.ebd.6401252.
Data sourcesPubMed, Web of Knowledge, Scopus and Scielo.Study selectionTwo reviewers identified studies supervised by a third. Observational studies which investigated the association between developmental defects of enamel and dental caries in the primary dentition, which were assessed by clinical examination and published in English, Spanish or Portuguese.Data extraction and synthesisQuality of research was assessed using the critical appraisal checklist from the Joanna Briggs Institute. Meta-analysis was conducted using crude and adjusted association measures (relative risk and odds ratio) with 95% confidence intervals. Combined results were presented as pooled odds ratio, and where necessary were estimated using fixed and random effect models. If heterogeneity was encountered in results, a random effect model was used. Bias was assessed using a funnel plot and the Egger test.ResultsEighteen studies were included in the systematic review and sixteen in meta-analysis; two out of the 16 were cohort studies, the rest being cross-sectional. Twelve of the studies included were conducted in low-income countries. The Egger test showed a degree of bias in some of the studies included. The authors found children with diffuse opacities or hypoplasia had higher odds of having dental caries (OR 1.42, 95% CI; 1.15-1.76; OR 4.29% CI 2.24-8.15), however the presence of demarcated opacities did not show higher odds of caries (OR 2.62, 95% CI 0.85-8.12).ConclusionsThe findings demonstrated an association between developmental defects of enamel and dental caries in the primary dentition. A preventive approach to dental caries and attention to children with enamel defects appears as a useful health promotion and public health strategy. At the individual level, clinicians should be aware that children with enamel defects could require more frequent visits to the dental office in order to reduce the risk of dental caries.
数据来源
PubMed、Web of Knowledge、Scopus和Scielo。
研究选择
两名评审员识别研究,并由第三名评审员监督。纳入通过临床检查评估、以英文、西班牙文或葡萄牙文发表的观察性研究,这些研究调查了乳牙列中牙釉质发育缺陷与龋齿之间的关联。
数据提取与综合
使用乔安娜·布里格斯研究所的批判性评价清单评估研究质量。采用粗关联度和调整后的关联度指标(相对风险和比值比)及95%置信区间进行荟萃分析。合并结果以合并比值比呈现,必要时使用固定效应模型和随机效应模型进行估计。若结果存在异质性,则使用随机效应模型。采用漏斗图和埃格检验评估偏倚。
结果
系统评价纳入18项研究,荟萃分析纳入16项研究;16项研究中有2项为队列研究,其余为横断面研究。纳入的研究中有12项在低收入国家开展。埃格检验显示部分纳入研究存在一定程度的偏倚。作者发现,患有弥漫性浑浊或发育不全的儿童患龋齿的几率更高(比值比1.42,95%置信区间:1.15 - 1.76;比值比4.29,95%置信区间2.24 - 8.15),然而界限清晰的浑浊情况并未显示出更高的患龋几率(比值比2.62,95%置信区间0.85 - 8.12)。
结论
研究结果表明乳牙列中牙釉质发育缺陷与龋齿之间存在关联。预防龋齿的方法以及关注牙釉质缺陷儿童似乎是一项有益的健康促进和公共卫生策略。在个体层面,临床医生应意识到牙釉质缺陷儿童可能需要更频繁地就诊牙科诊所,以降低患龋齿的风险。