Foo Valencia Hui Xian, Tan Sarah En Mei, Chen David Ziyou, Perera Shamira A, Sabayanagam Charumathi, Fenwick Eva Katie, Wong Tina T, Lamoureux Ecosse L
Singapore National Eye Centre, Singapore.
Tan Tock Seng Hospital, Singapore.
Clin Ophthalmol. 2017 Oct 13;11:1849-1857. doi: 10.2147/OPTH.S138668. eCollection 2017.
The aim of this study was to evaluate patients' dissatisfaction with overall and specific aspects of a tertiary glaucoma service and to determine their independent factors, including intraocular pressure (IOP) and visual acuity (VA).
Patients, aged ≥21 years, from a specialist glaucoma service in a tertiary eye hospital in Singapore for at least 6 months, were recruited for this cross-sectional study between March and June 2014. All consenting patients completed a 7-area glaucoma-specific satisfaction questionnaire and one item related to satisfaction with overall glaucoma care. We determined the top three areas of dissatisfaction and overall dissatisfaction with the glaucoma service. We also explored the independent factors associated with overall and specific areas of patients' dissatisfaction with their glaucoma care, including VA and IOP by using logistic regression models.
Of the 518 patients recruited, 438 (84.6%) patients completed the study. Patients' dissatisfaction with the overall glaucoma service was 7.5%. The three areas of glaucoma service with the highest dissatisfaction rates were as follows: 1) explanation of test results (24.8%); 2) explanation of glaucoma complications (23.7%); and 3) advice on managing glaucoma (23.5%). Patients who were dissatisfied with the overall service had a worse mean VA compared with satisfied patients (logarithm of the minimum angle of resolution =0.41±0.43 vs 0.27±0.49, =0.005), whereas mean IOP remained well-controlled in both the groups (13.55±2.46 mmHg vs 14.82±2.86 mmHg, =0.014). In adjusted models, factors associated with overall dissatisfaction with glaucoma care included a pre-university education and above (odds ratio [OR] =8.06, 95% CI =1.57-41.27) and lower IOP (OR =0.83, 95% CI =0.71-0.98).
Although less than one tenth of glaucoma patients were dissatisfied with the overall glaucoma service, one in four patients were dissatisfied with three specific aspects of care. A lower IOP, ironically, and education level were associated with overall dissatisfaction. Improving patients' understanding of glaucoma test results, glaucoma complications, and disease management may increase patient satisfaction levels.
本研究旨在评估患者对三级青光眼服务整体及具体方面的不满情况,并确定其独立影响因素,包括眼压(IOP)和视力(VA)。
招募来自新加坡一家三级眼科医院专科青光眼服务部门、年龄≥21岁且至少就诊6个月的患者,于2014年3月至6月进行这项横断面研究。所有同意参与的患者均完成一份7个领域的青光眼特异性满意度问卷以及一项与青光眼整体护理满意度相关的问题。我们确定了对青光眼服务不满的前三个领域以及整体不满情况。我们还通过逻辑回归模型探究了与患者对青光眼护理的整体及具体领域不满相关的独立因素,包括视力和眼压。
在招募的518名患者中,438名(84.6%)患者完成了研究。患者对青光眼服务整体的不满率为7.5%。青光眼服务中不满率最高的三个领域如下:1)检查结果解释(24.8%);2)青光眼并发症解释(23.7%);3)青光眼管理建议(23.5%)。与满意的患者相比,对整体服务不满的患者平均视力更差(最小分辨角对数=0.41±0.43 vs 0.27±0.49,P=0.005),而两组患者的平均眼压均控制良好(13.55±2.46 mmHg vs 14.82±2.86 mmHg,P=0.014)。在调整模型中,与对青光眼护理整体不满相关的因素包括大学预科及以上学历(比值比[OR]=8.06,95%置信区间[CI]=1.57 - 41.27)和较低的眼压(OR=0.83,95% CI=0.71 - 0.98)。
尽管不到十分之一的青光眼患者对青光眼服务整体不满,但四分之一的患者对护理的三个具体方面不满。具有讽刺意味的是,较低的眼压和教育水平与整体不满相关。提高患者对青光眼检查结果、青光眼并发症及疾病管理的理解可能会提高患者满意度。