Almirall José, Fortin Martin
Department of Family Medicine and Emergency Medicine, Université de Sherbrooke, Sherbrooke, Québec, Canada, and Centre de santé et de services sociaux de Chicoutimi, Chicoutimi, Québec, Canada.
J Comorb. 2013 Oct 8;3:4-9. doi: 10.15256/joc.2013.3.22. eCollection 2013.
Consensus on terminology for multiple diseases is lacking. Because of the clinical relevance and social impact of multiple concurrent diseases, it is important that concepts are clear.
To highlight the diversity of terms in the literature referring to the presence of multiple concurrent diseases/conditions and make recommendations.
A bibliometric analysis of English-language publications indexed in the MEDLINE database from 1970 to 2012 for the terms and , and a review of definitions of found in English-language publications indexed from 1970 to 2012 in the MEDLINE and SCOPUS databases.
was used in 67,557 publications, in 434, and the other terms in three to 31 publications. At least 144 publications used the term without referring to an index disease. Thirteen general definitions of were identified, but only two were frequently used (91% of publications). The most frequently used definition (48% of publications) was "". Multimorbidity was not defined in 51% of the publications using the term.
was overwhelmingly used to describe any clinical entity coexisting with an index disease under study. was the term most frequently used when no index disease was designated. Several definitions of were found. However, most authors using the term did not define it. The use of clearly defined terms in the literature is recommended until a general consensus on the terminology of multiple coexistent diseases is reached. Journal of Comorbidity 2013;3:4-9.
对于多种疾病的术语尚无共识。由于多种并发疾病的临床相关性和社会影响,概念清晰很重要。
强调文献中提及多种并发疾病/状况时术语的多样性并提出建议。
对1970年至2012年MEDLINE数据库中索引的英文出版物进行文献计量分析,检索词为 和 ,并回顾1970年至2012年MEDLINE和SCOPUS数据库中索引的英文出版物中 的定义。
67,557篇出版物使用了 ,434篇使用了 ,其他术语在3至31篇出版物中使用。至少144篇出版物使用 一词时未提及索引疾病。确定了 的13种一般定义,但只有两种被频繁使用(占出版物的91%)。最常使用的定义(占出版物的48%)是“”。使用该术语的出版物中有51%未定义多病共存。
绝大多数情况下 用于描述与所研究的索引疾病共存的任何临床实体。当未指定索引疾病时, 是最常使用的术语。发现了 的几种定义。然而,大多数使用该术语的作者并未对其进行定义。在就多种共存疾病的术语达成普遍共识之前,建议在文献中使用明确定义的术语。《共病杂志》2013年;3:4 - 9。