Voinov Pavel Valeryevich, Sebanz Natalie, Knoblich Günther
Department of Cognitive Science, Central European University, Budapest, Hungary.
PLoS One. 2017 Nov 2;12(11):e0187428. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0187428. eCollection 2017.
Others' perceptual judgments tend to have strong effects on our own, and can improve perceptual judgments when task partners engage in communication. The present study investigated whether individuals benefit from others' perceptual judgments in indirect interactions, where outcomes of individual decisions can be observed in a shared environment. Participants located a target in a 2D projection of a 3D container either from two complementary viewpoints (Experiment 1), or from a single viewpoint (Experiment 2). Uncertainty about the target location was high on the front-back dimension and low on the left-right dimension. The results showed that pairs of participants benefitted from taking turns in providing judgments. When each member of the pair had access to one complementary perspective, the pair achieved the same level of accuracy as when the two individuals had access to both complimentary perspectives and better performance than when the two individuals had access to only one perspective. These findings demonstrate the important role of a shared environment for successful integration of perceptual information while highlighting limitations in assigning appropriate weights to others' judgments.
他人的感知判断往往会对我们自己的判断产生强烈影响,并且当任务伙伴进行交流时,还能改善感知判断。本研究调查了在间接互动中,个体是否能从他人的感知判断中受益,在这种间接互动中,个体决策的结果可以在共享环境中被观察到。参与者在一个三维容器的二维投影中,从两个互补视角(实验1)或单一视角(实验2)定位一个目标。目标位置在前后维度上的不确定性高,而在左右维度上的不确定性低。结果表明,参与者成对轮流提供判断时会从中受益。当一对中的每个成员都能获取一个互补视角时,这一对所达到的准确率与两人都能获取两个互补视角时相同,且比两人都只能获取一个视角时表现更好。这些发现证明了共享环境在成功整合感知信息方面的重要作用,同时也凸显了在为他人的判断赋予适当权重时存在的局限性。