Groven Karen Synne, Heggen Kristin
a Institute of Health and Society, Faculty of Medicine , University of Oslo , Oslo , Norway.
b Department of Health and society , Oslo University College , Norway.
Physiother Theory Pract. 2018 May;34(5):346-358. doi: 10.1080/09593985.2017.1400140. Epub 2017 Nov 9.
Obesity is regarded as a modern lifestyle problem, causing illness, stigma, discrimination, and psychological problems. To help patients avoid these problems, physiotherapists increasingly engage in lifestyle programs specialized in weight loss.
To explore how physiotherapists' encounters with patients diagnosed as "obese" acquire significance for their development as clinicians.
The material draws on semi-structured interviews with eight physiotherapists. We conducted a thematic analysis inspired by van Manen's hermeneutic-phenomenological approach combined with Kvale and Brinkman's critical approach.
The analysis identified the following four themes: 1) Striving to find one's own style of communication; 2) Relating to bodily discrepancies; 3) Developing clinical competence through bodily encounters; and 4) Gaining insight into the dilemmas of group-based lifestyle programs. Taken together, our findings highlight bodily encounters between patients and physiotherapists as an invaluable source of insight. Such insight can shape physiotherapists' development as clinicians inspiring them to develop their unique ways of communicating so that patients diagnosed as obese can feel empowerment rather than failure and shame. At the same time, our findings point to the need of critically reflecting on ones' own approach entering a double role of both controller and supporter. As such, our findings complicate and extend previous work on stigma and shame.
Our research leads us to conclude that more emphasis on critical thinking in physiotherapy is necessary. We suggest that this should be given more priority in research, education, as well as in clinical practice.
肥胖被视为一种现代生活方式问题,会引发疾病、污名、歧视和心理问题。为帮助患者避免这些问题,物理治疗师越来越多地参与到专门的减肥生活方式项目中。
探讨物理治疗师与被诊断为“肥胖”的患者的接触如何对其作为临床医生的发展具有重要意义。
材料取自对八位物理治疗师的半结构化访谈。我们采用了受范曼诠释现象学方法启发并结合克瓦尔和布林克曼批判方法的主题分析。
分析确定了以下四个主题:1)努力找到自己的沟通方式;2)应对身体差异;3)通过身体接触培养临床能力;4)深入了解基于群体的生活方式项目的困境。总体而言,我们的研究结果突出了患者与物理治疗师之间的身体接触是一种宝贵的洞察来源。这种洞察可以塑造物理治疗师作为临床医生的发展,激励他们发展独特的沟通方式,使被诊断为肥胖的患者能感到被赋能而非失败和羞耻。同时,我们的研究结果指出需要批判性地反思自己进入控制者和支持者双重角色的方法。因此,我们的研究结果使先前关于污名和羞耻的研究变得复杂并有所扩展。
我们的研究使我们得出结论,物理治疗中需要更加强调批判性思维。我们建议在研究、教育以及临床实践中应给予其更高的优先级。