Faculty of Health and Social Sciences, The Hong Kong Polytechnic University, Hung Hom, Hong Kong.
School of Nursing, The Hong Kong Polytechnic University, Hung Hom, Hong Kong.
Complement Ther Clin Pract. 2017 Nov;29:169-184. doi: 10.1016/j.ctcp.2017.09.006. Epub 2017 Sep 18.
Support for breastfeeding has been a matter of considerable interest in healthcare. In the field of traditional and complementary medicine, the effectiveness of auricular therapy on lactation has been investigated by several clinical studies.
This review was mainly performed to assess the current evidence of auricular therapy on lactation. The objectives were to assess the current evidence of AT for lactation, examine the intervention protocols and outcome measures adopted by the studies included, and inform clinical application and future research in this area.
Systematic review.
Narrative synthesis methodology was used to incorporate diverse forms of evidence within this systematic review.
Twenty-three randomized controlled trials and three non-randomized controlled trials were identified, of which 25 studies applied auricular acupressure with vaccaria seeds as the sole form of auricular therapy. Relative risks calculated on the onset of lactation and milk production are all less than 1. These results indicate that women in the auricular therapy group lactated earlier than their counterparts in the control group and the risk of low milk production was reduced while on auricular therapy. Absolute risk differences showed magnitude of effect ranging from small to medium. Standardized mean differences calculated on serum prolactin data generally favor auricular therapy over routine care. Overall, mothers treated by auricular therapy exhibited better lactation outcomes.
The available data show evidence of benefits for postpartum lactation from auricular therapy. However, research using a more stringent design, standardized protocol, and valid outcome measures are warranted before it can be considered to be evidence-based practice. Issues from the current studies are highlighted and may serve to inform future trials.
母乳喂养的支持一直是医疗保健领域关注的焦点。在传统和补充医学领域,已有多项临床研究探讨了耳穴疗法对哺乳的有效性。
本次综述主要旨在评估耳穴疗法对哺乳的现有证据。目的是评估 AT 对哺乳的当前证据,检查纳入研究采用的干预方案和结果测量指标,并为该领域的临床应用和未来研究提供信息。
系统综述。
采用叙述性综合方法将本系统综述中的各种形式的证据纳入其中。
确定了 23 项随机对照试验和 3 项非随机对照试验,其中 25 项研究应用了耳穴按压加王不留行籽作为唯一形式的耳穴疗法。关于泌乳和产奶量的相对风险均小于 1。这些结果表明,耳穴治疗组的女性比对照组更早开始泌乳,并且在接受耳穴治疗时,低产奶量的风险降低。计算血清催乳素数据的标准均数差值通常有利于耳穴治疗而非常规护理。总的来说,接受耳穴治疗的母亲表现出更好的哺乳结果。
现有数据表明,耳穴疗法对产后哺乳有一定益处。然而,在将其视为基于证据的实践之前,需要使用更严格的设计、标准化方案和有效的结果测量指标进行研究。当前研究中的问题被强调,并可能为未来的试验提供信息。