Story Chandra R, Knutson Douglas, Brown Jameisha B, Spears-Laniox Erica, Harvey Idethia Shevon, Gizlice Ziya, Whitt-Glover Melicia C
Department of Health and Human Performance, Middle Tennessee State University, Murfreesboro, TN, USA.
Department of Psychology, Southern Illinois University at Carbondale, Carbondale, IL, USA.
Health Educ Res. 2017 Dec 1;32(6):513-523. doi: 10.1093/her/cyx062.
African-American women report higher levels of chronic conditions and church attendance relative to the overall US population. Therefore, efforts have increased over the past decade to design church-based health promotion programs. The present study compared changes in religiosity, religious social support and general social support across time within a church-based physical activity study. In a clustered randomized controlled trial, 31 churches and ∼15 African-American women per church were recruited to participate. Churches were randomized to one of three 10-month programs to promote physical activity: faith-integrated (FI), non-faith integrated (NFI) or self-guided control program (C). Comparisons were made between baseline and 10-month time points to assess differences over time. A significant reduction in general social support was observed across all groups. Private religious practices and religious emotional support received increases in C and FI, respectively. Prior research findings and the current study highlight difficulty in demonstrating strong, unilateral changes in religiosity, social support and health. Additional research is needed to identify more accurate measures of these concepts. Findings from the current study have implications for the role of social support in future church-based health promotion studies.
与美国总体人口相比,非裔美国女性报告的慢性病水平更高,且去教堂做礼拜的频率也更高。因此,在过去十年里,为设计以教堂为基础的健康促进项目所做的努力有所增加。本研究在一项以教堂为基础的体育活动研究中,比较了不同时间内宗教虔诚度、宗教社会支持和一般社会支持的变化。在一项整群随机对照试验中,招募了31所教堂,每所教堂约15名非裔美国女性参与。教堂被随机分配到三个为期10个月的促进体育活动的项目之一:信仰融合(FI)、非信仰融合(NFI)或自我指导控制项目(C)。在基线和10个月时间点之间进行比较,以评估随时间的差异。所有组的一般社会支持均显著减少。私人宗教活动和宗教情感支持在C组和FI组中分别有所增加。先前的研究结果和当前的研究都凸显了在证明宗教虔诚度、社会支持和健康方面的强烈、单方面变化存在困难。需要更多的研究来确定这些概念更准确的衡量标准。当前研究的结果对社会支持在未来以教堂为基础的健康促进研究中的作用具有启示意义。