Edvardsen Hilde Erøy, Tverborgvik Torill, Frost Joachim, Rogde Sidsel, Morild Inge, Waal Helge, Clausen Thomas, Slørdal Lars, Vindenes Vigdis
Department of Forensic Sciences, Oslo University Hospital, Post Box 4950, Nydalen, N-0424 Oslo, Norway.
Department of Forensic Sciences, Oslo University Hospital, Post Box 4950, Nydalen, N-0424 Oslo, Norway.
Forensic Sci Int. 2017 Dec;281:127-133. doi: 10.1016/j.forsciint.2017.10.045. Epub 2017 Nov 6.
In toxicology, international classification systems focus on single intoxicants as the cause of death. It is, however, well known that very few drug related deaths are caused by a single substance and that information concerning the drug concentrations as well as the combinations of drugs are essential in order to ascertain the cause of death. The aim of the study was to assess whether those prone to fatal intoxications differ significantly from chronic drug users - in terms of demographics and drug exposure patterns.
Fatal psychoactive drug intoxications in Norway during 2012, where a forensic autopsy including toxicological analysis were performed, were included. Analytical findings in blood were compared with concentrations in blood from apprehended drivers under the influence of drugs and ethanol (DUID) during the same time period. The opioid and benzodiazepine concentrations were assessed as morphine and diazepam equivalents, respectively, in order to compare concentrations across the different groups.
A total of 194 autopsy cases and 4811 DUID cases were included. Opioids were detected in around 90% of the drug intoxication cases, but in only 16% of the DUID cases. The number of substances detected in fatal intoxications was 4.9 compared to 2.6 in the DUID cases. The total opioid concentrations were significantly higher in the fatal intoxication cases compared to DUID cases (229ng/mL versus 56.9ng/mL morphine equivalents, respectively). Benzodiazepines were detected in 90% of the fatal cases. Only one fatal opioid mono-intoxication was found; a case with a very high methadone concentration (1238ng/mL).
Mono-intoxication with heroin was not seen in any of the fatal intoxications in Norway, and single drug intoxications were rare (1.5%). Fatal intoxications were caused by a combination of drugs with significantly more substances as well as higher total drug concentrations among the fatal cases compared to the DUID cases. The combination of opioids and benzodiazepines seemed to represent an increased risk of death.
The total load of drugs influence the degree of intoxication and the total concentration level must be considered, including the total number of substances. Our findings imply that international statistics regarding an opioid being the main intoxicant should have a shift in focus towards combinations of drugs (especially opioids and benzodiazepines) as a major risk factor for fatal drug overdoses.
在毒理学中,国际分类系统将单一毒物视为死亡原因。然而,众所周知,很少有与药物相关的死亡是由单一物质导致的,为了确定死亡原因,有关药物浓度以及药物组合的信息至关重要。本研究的目的是评估那些容易发生致命中毒的人与慢性吸毒者在人口统计学和药物暴露模式方面是否存在显著差异。
纳入2012年挪威发生的致命精神活性药物中毒案例,这些案例均进行了包括毒理学分析在内的法医尸检。将血液中的分析结果与同期因药物和乙醇影响而被逮捕的司机(DUID)血液中的浓度进行比较。为了比较不同组之间的浓度,阿片类药物和苯二氮卓类药物的浓度分别以吗啡当量和地西泮当量进行评估。
共纳入194例尸检案例和4811例DUID案例。在约90%的药物中毒案例中检测到阿片类药物,但在仅16%的DUID案例中检测到。致命中毒案例中检测到的物质数量为4.9种,而DUID案例中为2.6种。与DUID案例相比,致命中毒案例中的阿片类药物总浓度显著更高(分别为229纳克/毫升和56.9纳克/毫升吗啡当量)。90%的致命案例中检测到苯二氮卓类药物。仅发现一例致命的阿片类药物单一中毒案例,该案例中美沙酮浓度非常高(1238纳克/毫升)。
在挪威的任何致命中毒案例中均未发现海洛因单一中毒情况,单一药物中毒很少见(1.5%)。与DUID案例相比,致命中毒是由药物组合导致的,致命案例中的物质种类明显更多,药物总浓度也更高。阿片类药物和苯二氮卓类药物的组合似乎增加了死亡风险。
药物的总负荷会影响中毒程度,必须考虑总浓度水平,包括物质的总数。我们的研究结果表明,关于阿片类药物是主要毒物的国际统计数据应将重点转向药物组合(尤其是阿片类药物和苯二氮卓类药物),将其作为致命药物过量的主要风险因素。