Thompson P D, Cullinane E M, Nugent A M, Sady M A, Sady S P
Division of Cardiology, Miriam Hospital, Providence, Rhode Island 02906.
Am J Med. 1989 Jan 23;86(1B):104-9. doi: 10.1016/0002-9343(89)90143-5.
We evaluated maximal performance during cycle ergometry and treadmill exercise in 14 hypertensive male joggers treated with prazosin or atenolol in an unblinded, placebo-controlled, crossover design. Maximal oxygen uptake was measured during both exercise modalities; cardiac output was measured only during cycle ergometry using the acetylene rebreathing technique. Both drugs reduced resting systolic and diastolic blood pressures. Prazosin reduced total peripheral resistance during submaximal exercise but had little effect on maximal cycle and treadmill performance. Atenolol, in contrast, reduced treadmill duration, maximal oxygen uptake, and heart rate compared with placebo. Atenolol also increased stroke volume and the arterial venous oxygen difference and reduced cardiac output during cycle exercise. Both drugs produced similar reductions in exercise diastolic pressure, but exercise systolic pressure was lower only during atenolol treatment. Prazosin was better tolerated by the subjects and was preferred by 10 of the men. We conclude that both drugs effectively reduced resting blood pressure, but that atenolol decreased exercise cardiac output and may impede exercise performance in physically active hypertensive subjects.
我们采用非盲法、安慰剂对照、交叉设计,评估了14名接受哌唑嗪或阿替洛尔治疗的高血压男性慢跑者在蹬车测力和跑步机运动中的最大运动能力。在两种运动方式中均测量了最大摄氧量;仅在蹬车测力过程中使用乙炔再呼吸技术测量心输出量。两种药物均降低了静息收缩压和舒张压。哌唑嗪在次最大运动时降低了总外周阻力,但对最大蹬车和跑步机运动能力影响不大。相比之下,与安慰剂相比,阿替洛尔缩短了跑步机运动时间、降低了最大摄氧量并降低了心率。阿替洛尔还增加了每搏输出量和动静脉氧差,并在蹬车运动时降低了心输出量。两种药物在运动舒张压方面的降低幅度相似,但仅在阿替洛尔治疗期间运动收缩压较低。受试者对哌唑嗪的耐受性更好,10名男性更喜欢哌唑嗪。我们得出结论,两种药物均有效降低了静息血压,但阿替洛尔降低了运动心输出量,可能会妨碍体力活动的高血压患者的运动能力。