Waisse Silvia
Postgraduate Programme in History of Science, Pontifical Catholic University of São Paulo, Brazil.
Homeopathy. 2017 Nov;106(4):250-259. doi: 10.1016/j.homp.2017.07.001. Epub 2017 Aug 7.
Medicine underwent a major crisis in the 18th century and several approaches, including homeopathy, were formulated to fill the void left by the fall of traditional Galenic medicine. While most of the literature deals with the reasons doctors had to shift to homeopathy, the patients' views became the focus of increasing scholarly attention along the past 20 years. In this article I present and discuss the current knowledge about the socio-demographic characteristics and medical complaints of patients who sought homeopathic care in the early 19th century in both private and institutional settings. The results show that not only patients from the higher and more educated classes sought homeopathic care, but a considerable number of individuals from the middle and lower strata did so too, even though they also had access to conventional hospitals. As to the clinical complaints, the reasons to seek homeopathic care were the typical ones for any general practice or hospital in the period considered.
医学在18世纪经历了一场重大危机,包括顺势疗法在内的几种方法应运而生,以填补传统盖伦医学衰落所留下的空白。虽然大多数文献讨论的是医生转向顺势疗法的原因,但在过去20年里,患者的观点越来越成为学术关注的焦点。在本文中,我将呈现并讨论目前关于19世纪初在私人和机构环境中寻求顺势疗法治疗的患者的社会人口特征和医疗诉求的知识。结果表明,不仅来自较高阶层和受过更多教育的患者寻求顺势疗法治疗,相当数量的中下层人士也这样做,尽管他们也可以去传统医院看病。至于临床诉求,在我们所考虑的这个时期,寻求顺势疗法治疗的原因与任何普通诊所或医院的典型原因相同。