Marsh J L, Grames L M, Holtman B
Cleft Palate and Craniofacial Deformities Institute, Washington University Medical Center, St. Louis, Missouri.
Cleft Palate J. 1989 Jan;26(1):46-50.
Preliminary results are reported from a prospective, alternated, single-institution study of the effect of intravelar veloplasty (IVV) upon postpalatoplasty velopharyngeal incompetence. Two senior surgeons standardized their operative procedures and then performed or directly supervised all surgery. Patients alternately had palatoplasty with or without IVV. One speech pathologist conducted all perceptual speech and language evaluations without knowledge of the surgical procedure when the children were 3 years of age. The IVV and non-IVV groups were similar with respect to cleft anatomy, mean age at palatoplasty, and audiograms at 1 and 3 years of age. The findings from a sample of 51 patients were that surgical retropositioning and approximation of the levator muscles during initial palatoplasty (1) did not demonstrably affect the incidence of postpalatoplasty auditory perceptual symptoms of velopharyngeal incompetence; (2) required a significantly longer operating time; (3) were costlier than the control procedure; and (4) did not have greater morbidity than the control procedure. These findings suggest either that there is no beneficial effect of IVV upon postpalatoplasty velopharyngeal competence or that the effect, if present, is of small magnitude.
本文报告了一项关于腭帆内成形术(IVV)对腭裂修复术后腭咽闭合不全影响的前瞻性、交替性、单机构研究的初步结果。两位资深外科医生规范了他们的手术操作,然后进行或直接监督所有手术。患者交替接受有或无IVV的腭裂修复术。当儿童3岁时,由一位言语病理学家在不知道手术方式的情况下进行所有言语和语言感知评估。IVV组和非IVV组在腭裂解剖结构、腭裂修复术时的平均年龄以及1岁和3岁时的听力图方面相似。对51例患者的样本研究结果表明,在初次腭裂修复术中对提肌进行手术复位和靠拢:(1)并未显著影响腭裂修复术后腭咽闭合不全的听觉感知症状发生率;(2)需要显著更长的手术时间;(3)比对照手术成本更高;(4)与对照手术相比,发病率并无更高。这些发现表明,要么IVV对腭裂修复术后腭咽功能没有有益影响,要么即便有影响,程度也很小。