Fronek J, Warren R F, Bowen M
Sports Medicine Service, Hospital for Special Surgery, New York, N.Y. 10021.
J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1989 Feb;71(2):205-16.
Twenty-four patients who had posterior subluxation of the glenohumeral joint were assigned to one of two groups on the basis of the severity of the symptoms. The sixteen patients in Group I, who had less severe symptoms, were treated with a physical therapy program that was based on exercises to strengthen muscles. The eleven patients in Group II (three of whom had no success with physical therapy when they were originally in Group I) had a posterior capsulorrhaphy, with or without a bone block. According to an over-all rating, Group I had a rate of success of 63 per cent, and Group II had a rate of success of 91 per cent. The patients who had more severe ligamentous laxity were not more likely to fail either of the treatment programs. Although voluntary subluxation may be a subtle but important indicator of underlying emotional difficulties, it appears that, in the patient who is emotionally stable, the ability to voluntarily subluxate the shoulder posteriorly is not associated with a negative prognosis for either non-surgical or surgical treatment. Patients who have moderately disabling posterior subluxation of the shoulder should be treated with an intensive program that is designed to strengthen muscles. Patients who have symptoms that are severely disabling or who have had no success with non-operative treatment should be treated with posterior capsulorrhaphy. When the posterior aspect of the glenoid is severely deficient and when the posterior portion of the capsule or the infraspinatus tendon is attenuated, a bone block should augment the reconstruction.
24例存在盂肱关节后脱位的患者根据症状严重程度被分为两组。I组的16例患者症状较轻,接受了以强化肌肉锻炼为基础的物理治疗方案。II组的11例患者(其中3例最初在I组时物理治疗无效)接受了后路关节囊缝合术,可选择加或不加植骨块。根据总体评估,I组的成功率为63%,II组的成功率为91%。韧带松弛更严重的患者在两种治疗方案中失败的可能性并未增加。尽管自愿性脱位可能是潜在情绪问题的一个微妙但重要的指标,但在情绪稳定的患者中,自愿性肩关节后脱位的能力似乎与非手术或手术治疗的不良预后无关。患有中度致残性肩关节后脱位的患者应接受旨在强化肌肉的强化治疗方案。有严重致残症状或非手术治疗无效的患者应接受后路关节囊缝合术。当肩胛盂后缘严重缺损,且关节囊后部或冈下肌腱变薄时,应加用植骨块以增强重建效果。