Björkeborn Mikael, Nilsson Henrik, Anderud Jonas
Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, Halmstad Hospital, Halmstad, Sweden.
Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, Växjö Hospital, Växjö, Sweden.
Clin Cosmet Investig Dent. 2017 Nov 15;9:111-116. doi: 10.2147/CCIDE.S138201. eCollection 2017.
To assess the quality of routine oral surgery referrals received at Halmstad Hospital and Växjö Hospital and to emphasize areas for improvement.
A retrospective study was performed on all routine oral surgery referrals received between 2014 and 2015 at both Halmstad Hospital and Växjö Hospital. A total of 1,891 referral letters were assessed for their quality against a predetermined checklist of basic requirements of a satisfactory referral. The referrals were also categorized according to if it was sent by a male, female, private dental service, or the Swedish Public Dental Health service.
A diagnosis was missing in 30% of all referrals. Radiographs and information about previous radiographic examinations were not included in 10% of the referrals. Of those referrals that included radiographs, only around half were deemed adequate for diagnostic purposes. The presenting complaint was missing in 40% of all referrals. Current medical history was absent in 40% and current medication was omitted in 60% of the referrals. Information about tobacco use was only included in 10% of all referrals. Overall, female referrers performed better than male colleagues. Private referrals more regularly included information about diagnosis, previous treatment, and current medication. On the other hand, referrals from the public dental health service more frequently included radiographs, tobacco use, and current medical history.
There is plenty of room for improving the standards of oral surgery referrals. We suggest that future electronic referral systems should only allow for submission once all of the essential information has been considered.
评估哈尔姆斯塔德医院和韦克舍医院接收的常规口腔外科转诊质量,并强调改进领域。
对哈尔姆斯塔德医院和韦克舍医院在2014年至2015年期间接收的所有常规口腔外科转诊进行回顾性研究。根据一份预先确定的关于满意转诊基本要求的清单,对总共1891封转诊信的质量进行评估。这些转诊信还根据发送者是男性、女性、私人牙科服务机构还是瑞典公共牙科保健服务机构进行分类。
所有转诊中有30%缺少诊断信息。10%的转诊中未包含X光片及以往X光检查的信息。在那些包含X光片的转诊中,只有约一半被认为对诊断有足够帮助。所有转诊中有40%缺少主诉。40%的转诊中没有当前病史,60%的转诊中遗漏了当前用药情况。只有10%的转诊包含了吸烟情况的信息。总体而言,女性转诊者的表现优于男性同事。私人转诊更经常包含诊断、既往治疗和当前用药的信息。另一方面,公共牙科保健服务机构的转诊更频繁地包含X光片、吸烟情况和当前病史。
口腔外科转诊标准有很大的改进空间。我们建议未来的电子转诊系统应在所有基本信息都已提供后才允许提交。