Solomon Sunil S, McFall Allison M, Lucas Gregory M, Srikrishnan Aylur K, Kumar Muniratnam S, Anand Santhanam, Quinn Thomas C, Celentano David D, Mehta Shruti H
Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland, United States of America.
Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, Baltimore, Maryland, United States of America.
PLoS Med. 2017 Nov 28;14(11):e1002460. doi: 10.1371/journal.pmed.1002460. eCollection 2017 Nov.
A major barrier to achieving ambitious targets for global control of HIV and hepatitis C virus (HCV) is low levels of awareness of infection among key populations such as men who have sex with men (MSM) and people who inject drugs (PWID). We explored the potential of a strategy routinely used for surveillance in these groups, respondent-driven sampling (RDS), to be used as an intervention to identify HIV- and HCV-infected PWID and MSM who are unaware of their status and those who are viremic across 26 Indian cities at various epidemic stages.
Data were collected as part of the baseline assessment of an ongoing cluster-randomized trial. RDS was used to accrue participants at 27 sites (15 PWID sites and 12 MSM sites) selected to reflect varying stages of the HIV epidemic among MSM and PWID in India. A total of 56 seeds recruited a sample of 26,447 persons (approximately 1,000 participants per site) between October 1, 2012, and December 19, 2013. Across MSM sites (n = 11,997), the median age was 25 years and the median number of lifetime male partners was 8. Across PWID sites (n = 14,450), 92.4% were male, the median age was 30 years, and 87.5% reported injection in the prior 6 months. RDS identified 4,051 HIV-infected persons, of whom 2,325 (57.4%) were unaware of their HIV infection and 2,816 (69.5%) were HIV viremic. It also identified 5,777 HCV-infected persons, of whom 5,337 (92.4%) were unaware that they were infected with HCV and 4,728 (81.8%) were viremic. In the overall sample (both MSM and PWID), the prevalence of HIV-infected persons who were unaware of their status increased with sampling depth, from 7.9% in participants recruited in waves 1 through 5 to 12.8% among those recruited in waves 26 and above (p-value for trend < 0.001). The overall detection rate of people unaware of their HIV infection was 0.5 persons per day, and the detection rate of HIV-infected persons with viremia (regardless of their awareness status) was 0.7 per day. The detection rate of HIV viremic individuals was positively associated with underlying HIV prevalence and the prevalence of HIV viremia (linear regression coefficient per 1-percentage-point increase in prevalence: 0.05 and 0.07, respectively). The median detection rate of PWID who were unaware of their HCV infection was 2.5 per day. The cost of identifying 1 unaware HIV-infected individual ranged from US$51 to US$2,072 across PWID sites and from US$189 to US$5,367 across MSM sites. The mean additional cost of identifying 1 unaware HCV-infected PWID was US$13 (site range: US$7-US$140). Limitations of the study include the exclusivity of study sites to India, lack of prior HIV/HCV diagnosis confirmation with clinic records, and lack of cost data from other case-finding approaches commonly used in India.
In this study, RDS was able to rapidly identify at nominal cost a substantial number of unaware and viremic HIV-infected and HCV-infected individuals who were currently not being reached by existing programs and who were at high risk for transmission. Combining RDS (or other network-driven recruitment approaches) with strategies focused on linkage to care, particularly in high-burden settings, may be a viable option for achieving the 90-90-90 targets in key populations in resource-limited settings.
在实现全球控制艾滋病毒和丙型肝炎病毒(HCV)宏伟目标的道路上,一个主要障碍是关键人群如男男性行为者(MSM)和注射吸毒者(PWID)对感染的知晓率较低。我们探讨了一种常用于这些群体监测的策略,即应答驱动抽样(RDS),能否作为一种干预措施,以识别在印度26个处于不同流行阶段城市中未意识到自身感染艾滋病毒和HCV的PWID及MSM,以及病毒血症患者。
作为一项正在进行的整群随机试验基线评估的一部分收集数据。RDS用于在27个地点(15个PWID地点和12个MSM地点)招募参与者,这些地点的选择旨在反映印度MSM和PWID中艾滋病毒流行的不同阶段。2012年10月1日至2013年12月19日期间,共56名种子招募了26447人(每个地点约1000名参与者)。在MSM地点(n = 11997),中位年龄为25岁,终生男性伴侣的中位数为8个。在PWID地点(n = 14450),92.4%为男性,中位年龄为30岁,87.5%报告在过去6个月内有注射行为。RDS识别出4051名艾滋病毒感染者,其中2325人(57.4%)未意识到自己感染艾滋病毒,2816人(69.5%)为艾滋病毒血症患者。它还识别出5777名HCV感染者,其中5337人(92.4%)未意识到自己感染了HCV,4728人(81.8%)为病毒血症患者。在总体样本(MSM和PWID)中,未意识到自身感染艾滋病毒者的患病率随抽样深度增加,从第1至5轮招募的参与者中的7.9%增至第26轮及以上招募者中的12.8%(趋势p值<0.001)。未意识到自身感染艾滋病毒者的总体检出率为每天0.5人/天,艾滋病毒血症感染者(无论其知晓状况如何)的检出率为每天0.7人/天。艾滋病毒血症个体的检出率与潜在艾滋病毒患病率和艾滋病毒血症患病率呈正相关(患病率每增加1个百分点的线性回归系数分别为0.05和0.07)。未意识到自身感染HCV的PWID的中位检出率为每天2.5人。在PWID地点,识别1名未意识到感染艾滋病毒的个体的成本从51美元到2072美元不等,在MSM地点则从189美元到5367美元不等。识别1名未意识到感染HCV的PWID的平均额外成本为13美元(地点范围:7美元至140美元)。该研究的局限性包括研究地点仅限于印度,缺乏与临床记录进行艾滋病毒/HCV诊断确认的前期数据,以及缺乏印度常用的其他病例发现方法的成本数据。
在本研究中,RDS能够以较低成本迅速识别出大量未意识到感染且处于病毒血症状态的艾滋病毒感染者和HCV感染者,这些人目前未被现有项目覆盖且具有高传播风险。将RDS(或其他基于网络的招募方法)与侧重于护理联系的策略相结合,特别是在高负担环境中,可能是在资源有限环境中实现关键人群90-90-90目标的可行选择。