Sifaki-Pistolla Dimitra, Chatzea Vasiliki-Eirini, Markaki Adelais, Kritikos Kyriakos, Petelos Elena, Lionis Christos
Clinic of Social and Family Medicine, School of Medicine, University of Crete, University Campus, Voutes, P.O. Box 2208, Heraklion, 71003, Crete, Crete, Greece.
School of Nursing, University of Alabama at Birmingham, Birmingham, USA.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2017 Nov 29;17(1):788. doi: 10.1186/s12913-017-2702-5.
Despite several countrywide attempts to strengthen and standardise the primary healthcare (PHC) system, Greece is still lacking a sustainable, policy-based model of integrated services. The aim of our study was to identify operational integration levels through existing patient care pathways and to recommend an alternative PHC model for optimum integration.
The study was part of a large state-funded project, which included 22 randomly selected PHC units located across two health regions of Greece. Dimensions of operational integration in PHC were selected based on the work of Kringos and colleagues. A five-point Likert-type scale, coupled with an algorithm, was used to capture and transform theoretical framework features into measurable attributes. PHC services were grouped under the main categories of chronic care, urgent/acute care, preventive care, and home care. A web-based platform was used to assess patient pathways, evaluate integration levels and propose improvement actions. Analysis relied on a comparison of actual pathways versus optimal, the latter ones having been identified through literature review.
Overall integration varied among units. The majority (57%) of units corresponded to a basic level. Integration by type of PHC service ranged as follows: basic (86%) or poor (14%) for chronic care units, poor (78%) or basic (22%) for urgent/acute care units, basic (50%) for preventive care units, and partial or basic (50%) for home care units. The actual pathways across all four categories of PHC services differed from those captured in the optimum integration model. Certain similarities were observed in the operational flows between chronic care management and urgent/acute care management. Such similarities were present at the highest level of abstraction, but also in common steps along the operational flows.
Existing patient care pathways were mapped and analysed, and recommendations for an optimum integration PHC model were made. The developed web platform, based on a strong theoretical framework, can serve as a robust integration evaluation tool. This could be a first step towards restructuring and improving PHC services within a financially restrained environment.
尽管希腊在全国范围内多次尝试加强和规范初级卫生保健(PHC)系统,但仍缺乏一个可持续的、基于政策的综合服务模式。我们研究的目的是通过现有的患者护理路径确定运营整合水平,并推荐一种替代的初级卫生保健模式以实现最佳整合。
该研究是一个大型国家资助项目的一部分,该项目包括在希腊两个卫生区域随机选择的22个初级卫生保健单位。基于克林戈斯及其同事的工作,选择了初级卫生保健中运营整合的维度。使用五点李克特量表结合一种算法,将理论框架特征转化为可测量的属性。初级卫生保健服务分为慢性病护理、紧急/急性病护理、预防保健和家庭护理几大类。使用一个基于网络的平台来评估患者路径、评估整合水平并提出改进措施。分析依赖于实际路径与最佳路径的比较,后者是通过文献综述确定的。
各单位的整体整合情况各不相同。大多数(57%)单位处于基本水平。按初级卫生保健服务类型划分的整合情况如下:慢性病护理单位为基本(86%)或较差(14%),紧急/急性病护理单位为较差(78%)或基本(22%),预防保健单位为基本(50%),家庭护理单位为部分或基本(50%)。初级卫生保健服务所有四类的实际路径均与最佳整合模型中的路径不同。在慢性病护理管理和紧急/急性病护理管理的运营流程之间观察到某些相似之处。这些相似之处不仅存在于最高抽象层面,也存在于运营流程中的共同步骤中。
绘制并分析了现有的患者护理路径,并对最佳整合的初级卫生保健模式提出了建议。基于强大理论框架开发的网络平台可作为一个强大的整合评估工具。这可能是在财政受限环境下重组和改善初级卫生保健服务的第一步。