VA Ann Arbor Healthcare System, 2215 Fuller Road, Ann Arbor, MI 48105, United States.
VA Ann Arbor Healthcare System, 2215 Fuller Road, Ann Arbor, MI 48105, United States; Department of Psychiatry, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI 48109, United States.
J Subst Abuse Treat. 2018 Jan;84:1-8. doi: 10.1016/j.jsat.2017.10.006. Epub 2017 Oct 16.
Individuals with a substance use disorder (SUD) diagnosis are more than twice as likely to smoke cigarettes as the general population. Emerging research has suggested that treating a substance use disorder simultaneously with tobacco use leads to a higher rate of treatment success for both substances. Despite this, substance use treatment protocols tend not to focus on tobacco use; in fact, traditional substance use treatments often discourage patients from attempting to quit smoking. One rationale is that patients may not be motivated to quit smoking. In the current study, data from veterans enrolled in outpatient treatment for a SUD were examined to assess for general characteristics of smokers as compared to non-smokers as well as to examine motivation to quit smoking. Baseline (i.e., pre-treatment) data from 277 Veterans were used. Charts of smokers in the SUD clinic (SUDC) were reviewed to assess how smoking is handled by SUDC providers, and if smokers attempt cessation. Of 277, 163 (59%) SUDC patients reported that they currently smoke cigarettes (M=16.3 cigarettes per day, SD=11.1). Smokers in the clinic reported greater general impairment than nonsmokers on the Short Index of Problems, F(1248)=8.9, p=0.003, as well as greater specific impairment: Physical Problems, F(1258)=13.5, p=0.000; Interpersonal Problems, F(1262)=5.6, p=0.019; Intrapersonal Problems, F(1260)=6.5, p=0.011, and Social Responsibility, F(1262)=14.7, p=0.000. Smokers in the sample were marginally more anxious than their non-smoking counterparts as measured by the GAD-7, F(1254)=4.6, p=0.053, though they were not significantly more depressed (p=0.19). On a 1-10 scale, smokers reported moderate levels of importance (M=5.4, SD=3.1), readiness (M=5.6, SD=3.2), and confidence (M=5.0, SD=3.0) regarding quitting smoking. Review of smokers' medical records reveal that while SUDC providers assess tobacco use at intake (90%) and offer treatment (86.5%), a substantially small portion of smokers attempt cessation (41.1%) while enrolled in SUDC. Moreover, no patients were enrolled in smoking-specific behavioral interventions while in SUDC, though 78 patients did obtain nicotine replacement or another smoking cessation medication (41% were prescribed by a SUDC provider). Contrary to the belief that treatment-seeking substance users are not motivated to quit smoking, these preliminary analyses demonstrate that Veterans were at least contemplating quitting smoking while they were enrolled in substance use treatment. Further, there is evidence that cigarette smokers have greater impairment caused by substance use, suggesting that this subgroup is of particular high need. Specific treatment recommendations are discussed, including how behavioral health providers in SUD clinics may be better able to capitalize on patients' moderate motivation to quit at intake.
患有物质使用障碍(SUD)的个体吸烟的可能性是普通人群的两倍多。新出现的研究表明,同时治疗物质使用障碍和烟草使用会导致这两种物质的治疗成功率更高。尽管如此,物质使用治疗方案往往不关注烟草使用;事实上,传统的物质使用治疗往往不鼓励患者尝试戒烟。一个理由是患者可能没有戒烟的动力。在当前的研究中,对参加物质使用障碍门诊治疗的退伍军人的数据进行了检查,以评估吸烟者与不吸烟者的一般特征,并检查他们戒烟的动机。使用了 277 名退伍军人的基线(即治疗前)数据。对 SUD 诊所(SUDC)的吸烟者图表进行了审查,以评估 SUDC 提供者如何处理吸烟问题,以及吸烟者是否尝试戒烟。在 277 名退伍军人中,有 163 名(59%)报告他们目前吸烟(每天吸烟 16.3 支,标准差为 11.1)。与不吸烟者相比,诊所中的吸烟者在短期问题索引上表现出更大的一般障碍,F(1248)=8.9,p=0.003,以及更大的特定障碍:身体问题,F(1258)=13.5,p=0.000;人际问题,F(1262)=5.6,p=0.019;内在问题,F(1260)=6.5,p=0.011,和社会责任感,F(1262)=14.7,p=0.000。样本中的吸烟者在 GAD-7 上的焦虑程度略高于不吸烟者,F(1254)=4.6,p=0.053,尽管他们的抑郁程度没有显著差异(p=0.19)。在 1-10 的量表上,吸烟者报告戒烟的重要性(M=5.4,SD=3.1)、准备情况(M=5.6,SD=3.2)和信心(M=5.0,SD=3.0)处于中等水平。对吸烟者病历的审查显示,尽管 SUDC 提供者在入组时评估烟草使用情况(90%)并提供治疗(86.5%),但只有一小部分吸烟者(41.1%)在参加 SUDC 时尝试戒烟。此外,虽然有 78 名患者获得了尼古丁替代或其他戒烟药物(41%由 SUDC 提供者开具),但在 SUDC 期间没有患者参加专门针对吸烟的行为干预。与治疗寻求的物质使用者没有戒烟动力的信念相反,这些初步分析表明,退伍军人在参加物质使用治疗时至少正在考虑戒烟。此外,有证据表明,香烟吸烟者因物质使用而造成的损害更大,这表明这一亚组的需求特别高。讨论了具体的治疗建议,包括 SUD 诊所的行为健康提供者如何更好地利用患者在入组时的中等戒烟动力。