Ali Kamran, Jerreat Matthew, Zahra Daniel, Tredwin Christopher
Dr. Ali is Associate Professor and Consultant in Oral Surgery, Peninsula Dental School, Plymouth University, Plymouth, Devon, United Kingdom; Dr. Jerreat is Associate Professor and Consultant in Restorative Dentistry, Peninsula Dental School, Plymouth University, Plymouth, Devon, United Kingdom; Dr. Zahra is Senior Assessment Psychometrician, Peninsula Schools of Medicine and Dentistry, Plymouth University, Plymouth, Devon, United Kingdom; and Dr. Tredwin is Professor of Restorative Dentistry and Head of Peninsula Dental School, Plymouth University, Plymouth, Devon, United Kingdom.
J Dent Educ. 2017 Dec;81(12):1444-1450. doi: 10.21815/JDE.017.105.
Dental students are assessed using a range of methods in their final-year examinations. The aim of this study was to explore the correlations and predictive value of final-year dental students' performance on knowledge-based and clinical assessments. Examination data related to applied dental knowledge (ADK), exit case presentation (CP), and integrated structured clinical examination (ISCE) assessments for five consecutive cohorts of final-year students at one U.K. dental school from 2011-12 to 2015-16 were collated. The relationships between the scores produced by each assessment were investigated to explore the relative contributions of each to the understanding of students' abilities across the domains. The study utilized data from all 304 students: 147 (48.4%) females and 157 (51.6%) males. Significant positive correlations were found between ISCE and ADK performance (r(391)=0.42, p<0.001) as well as between ISCE and CP (r(391)=0.44, p<0.001). In addition, both ADK performance and CP performance were significant predictors (at p<0.001) of ISCE performance. This study provides important information about the relationship between these students' performance across knowledge (ADK) and clinical (ISCE and CP) domains and highlights their predictive value. Further research is required to establish if these findings can be generalized and to explore the correlations between performance of dental students before and after graduation.
牙科学生在其最后一年的考试中会通过一系列方法进行评估。本研究的目的是探讨牙科专业最后一年学生在基于知识的评估和临床评估中的表现之间的相关性及预测价值。整理了英国一所牙科学校2011 - 12年至2015 - 16年连续五个队列的最后一年学生的与应用牙科知识(ADK)、结业病例展示(CP)和综合结构化临床考试(ISCE)评估相关的考试数据。研究了各项评估产生的分数之间的关系,以探讨每项评估对理解学生在各个领域能力的相对贡献。该研究使用了所有304名学生的数据:147名(48.4%)女性和157名(51.6%)男性。发现ISCE与ADK成绩之间存在显著正相关(r(391)=0.42,p<0.001),ISCE与CP之间也存在显著正相关(r(391)=0.44,p<0.001)。此外,ADK成绩和CP成绩都是ISCE成绩的显著预测指标(p<0.001)。本研究提供了关于这些学生在知识(ADK)和临床(ISCE和CP)领域表现之间关系的重要信息,并突出了它们的预测价值。需要进一步研究以确定这些发现是否可以推广,并探讨牙科学生毕业前后表现之间的相关性。