Schaerli Sarah, Schulz Richard, Gascho Dominic, Enders Markus, Baumann Sandra, Thali Michael J, Bolliger Stephan A
Zurich Institute of Forensic Medicine, Department of Forensic Medicine and Imaging, University of Zurich, Winterthurerstrasse 190/52, CH-8057, Zurich, Switzerland.
Forensic Sci Med Pathol. 2018 Mar;14(1):31-41. doi: 10.1007/s12024-017-9937-7. Epub 2017 Dec 2.
We examined the possibility of inflicting serious injuries with sharp objects in an experimental setting by throwing four sharp objects from different distances and with different throwing techniques. Using an overarm-handle (OA/H), overarm-blade (OA/B), underarm-handle (UA/H), underarm-blade (UA/B) and thrust (T/H) throwing technique, 10 adults (sex ratio 1:1) threw a chef's knife, a skinning knife, a paring knife and office scissors from 4 m and 2 m distance at synthetic abdomen models made of 10% gelatin covered with synthetic skin. The amount of hits and penetrations of the target and their penetration depth were noted, as was the rotation of the blade tip towards the target along its flight trajectory. The chef's knife injury/hit ratio was 0.167/4 m and 0.160/2 m; the skinning knife recorded an injury/hit ratio of 0.087/4 m and 0.153/2 m; the paring knife of 0.087/4 m and 0.113/2 m; and the scissors 0.087/4 m and 0.067/2 m. Mean penetration depths were as follows: the chef's knife: 4 m, 4.42 cm, 2 m, 3.41 cm; the skinning knife: 4 m, 4.19 cm, 2 m, 4.11 cm; the paring knife: 4 m, 1.62 cm, 2 m, 1.55 cm; and the scissors: 4 m, 2.08 cm, 2 m, 0.95 cm. Handle-throw penetration-depths were: 4 m: 3.77 cm and 2 m: 2.86 cm; blade-throw depths were: 4 m: 3.14 cm and 2 m: 2.69 cm. Overarm-throw penetration-depths were: 4 m: 3.62 cm and 2 m: 3.25 cm; and underarm-throw penetration-depths were 4 m: 3.30 cm and 2 m: 2.30 cm. No thrust-throws with the paring knife and scissors could pierce the target. The tips pointed toward the target at angles of 60°-120°, earlier in handle-throws than blade-throws, especially with the paring knife and the scissors. When thrown, especially with a handle-held technique, heavier objects pierced more often and more deeply. Thrust-throws at short distances are unlikely to pierce a human.
我们在实验环境中,通过从不同距离、运用不同投掷技巧投掷四种尖锐物体,研究了使用尖锐物体造成重伤的可能性。10名成年人(男女比例1:1)采用过肩握柄式(OA/H)、过肩刀刃式(OA/B)、 underarm-handle(UA/H)、underarm-blade(UA/B)和刺击(T/H)投掷技巧,从4米和2米的距离向覆盖有合成皮肤的10%明胶制成的合成腹部模型投掷一把厨师刀、一把剥皮刀、一把削皮刀和办公剪刀。记录目标的命中和穿透数量及其穿透深度,以及刀尖在飞行轨迹上朝向目标的旋转情况。厨师刀的损伤/命中比在4米处为0.167,在2米处为0.160;剥皮刀的损伤/命中比在4米处为0.087,在2米处为0.153;削皮刀在4米处为0.087,在2米处为0.113;剪刀在4米处为0.087,在2米处为0.067。平均穿透深度如下:厨师刀:4米处为4.42厘米,2米处为3.41厘米;剥皮刀:4米处为4.19厘米,2米处为4.11厘米;削皮刀:4米处为1.62厘米,2米处为1.55厘米;剪刀:4米处为2.08厘米,2米处为0.95厘米。握柄投掷的穿透深度为:4米处3.77厘米,2米处2.86厘米;刀刃投掷深度为:4米处3.14厘米,2米处2.69厘米。过肩投掷的穿透深度为:4米处3.62厘米,2米处3.25厘米; underarm-throw的穿透深度为4米处3.30厘米,2米处2.30厘米。削皮刀和剪刀的刺击无法穿透目标。刀尖以60°-120°的角度指向目标,握柄投掷时比刀刃投掷时更早,尤其是削皮刀和剪刀。投掷时,尤其是采用握柄持物技巧时,较重的物体更常且更深地穿透目标。短距离的刺击不太可能穿透人体。