Jiang Lei, Wang Yun, Cai Bangyu, Wang Yueming, Wang Yiwen
Qiushi Academy for Advanced Studies, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou, China.
Department of Computer Science and Technology, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou, China.
Front Comput Neurosci. 2017 Nov 27;11:106. doi: 10.3389/fncom.2017.00106. eCollection 2017.
The event-related potential (ERP) is the brain response measured in electroencephalography (EEG), which reflects the process of human cognitive activity. ERP has been introduced into brain computer interfaces (BCIs) to communicate the computer with the subject's intention. Due to the low signal-to-noise ratio of EEG, most ERP studies are based on grand-averaging over many trials. Recently single-trial ERP detection attracts more attention, which enables real time processing tasks as rapid face identification. All the targets needed to be retrieved may appear only once, and there is no knowledge of target label for averaging. More interestingly, how the features contribute temporally spatially to single-trial ERP detection has not been fully investigated. In this paper, we propose to implement a local-learning-based (LLB) feature extraction method to investigate the importance of spatial-temporal components of ERP in a task of rapid face identification using single-trial detection. Comparing to previous methods, LLB method preserves the structure of EEG signal distribution, and analyze the importance of spatial-temporal components via optimization in feature space. As a data-driven methods, the weighting of the spatial-temporal component does not depend on the ERP detection method. The importance weights are optimized by making the targets more different from non-targets in feature space, and regularization penalty is introduced in optimization for sparse weights. This spatial-temporal feature extraction method is evaluated on the EEG data of 15 participants in performing a face identification task using rapid serial visual presentation paradigm. Comparing with other methods, the proposed spatial-temporal analysis method uses sparser (only 10% of the total) features, and could achieve comparable performance (98%) of single-trial ERP detection as the whole features across different detection methods. The interesting finding is that the N250 is the earliest temporal component that contributes to single-trial ERP detection in face identification. And the importance of N250 components is more laterally distributed toward the left hemisphere. We show that using only the left N250 component over-performs the right N250 in the face identification task using single-trial ERP detection. The finding is also important in building a fast and efficient (fewer electrodes) BCI system for rapid face identification.
事件相关电位(ERP)是在脑电图(EEG)中测量的大脑反应,它反映了人类认知活动的过程。ERP已被引入脑机接口(BCI),以便计算机与受试者的意图进行通信。由于EEG的信噪比低,大多数ERP研究基于对多次试验的总体平均。最近,单次试验ERP检测引起了更多关注,它能够实现诸如快速面部识别等实时处理任务。所有需要检索的目标可能只出现一次,并且没有用于平均的目标标签知识。更有趣的是,特征如何在时间和空间上对单次试验ERP检测做出贡献尚未得到充分研究。在本文中,我们提出实施一种基于局部学习的(LLB)特征提取方法,以研究在使用单次试验检测的快速面部识别任务中ERP时空成分的重要性。与以前的方法相比,LLB方法保留了EEG信号分布的结构,并通过在特征空间中进行优化来分析时空成分的重要性。作为一种数据驱动的方法,时空成分的加权不依赖于ERP检测方法。通过使目标在特征空间中与非目标更不同来优化重要性权重,并在优化中引入正则化惩罚以获得稀疏权重。这种时空特征提取方法在15名参与者使用快速序列视觉呈现范式执行面部识别任务的EEG数据上进行了评估。与其他方法相比,所提出的时空分析方法使用更稀疏的(仅占总数的10%)特征,并且在不同检测方法中作为整体特征能够实现与单次试验ERP检测相当的性能(98%)。有趣的发现是N250是在面部识别中对单次试验ERP检测做出贡献的最早时间成分。并且N250成分的重要性在更侧向的方向上向左半球分布。我们表明,在使用单次试验ERP检测的面部识别任务中,仅使用左侧N250成分比右侧N