Wilson Jane E, Smith Michael J, Lambert Tammy L, George David L, Bulkley Christina
University of Oklahoma College of Pharmacy, 1110 North Stonewall Avenue, Oklahoma City, OK 73117, United States.
Curr Pharm Teach Learn. 2017 Nov;9(6):1042-1054. doi: 10.1016/j.cptl.2017.07.018. Epub 2017 Sep 14.
The purpose of this article is to describe and assess the effectiveness of an innovative teaching approach in an advanced pharmacy practice experience (APPE) and leadership elective.
Three cohorts of students [(2014: n = 14), (2015: n = 17), (2016: n = 19)] were introduced to the photovoice (PV) method in their leadership APPE. PV required students to take, present, and discuss photographs within their cohorts. PV was used as a teaching method with the intention that the process would compel students to be involved in leadership development throughout experiential rotations, participate in discussions related to leadership development, and engage in creative activity. Group discussions from the class of 2014 were recorded and transcribed. Students from all cohorts were asked to participate in an electronic survey containing items based on PV learning objectives. All students were asked to participate in semi-structured interviews about PV.
The inductive coding method was used to identify themes from discussion transcripts. Analysis of themes revealed 51.5% of the PV photographs related to emotional intelligence. Development of others and strong teams were themes represented in 44.3% of photographs. Survey data indicated all respondents agreed PV was a valuable method to describe learning in leadership. Interview coding revealed themes related to emotional intelligence and development of teams.
The PV method was an effective teaching tool in a leadership APPE and elective course. PV is a teaching method to be utilized in a variety of experiential learning environments to better enhance the professional development of pharmacy students.
本文旨在描述和评估一种创新教学方法在高级药学实践经验(APPE)和领导力选修课程中的有效性。
三组学生[(2014年:n = 14),(2015年:n = 17),(2016年:n = 19)]在其领导力APPE课程中学习了照片讲述法(PV)。PV要求学生在小组内拍摄、展示和讨论照片。PV被用作一种教学方法,目的是促使学生在整个实践轮转过程中参与领导力发展,参与与领导力发展相关的讨论,并参与创造性活动。对2014级班级的小组讨论进行了录音和转录。要求所有组的学生参与一项基于PV学习目标的电子调查。要求所有学生参与关于PV的半结构化访谈。
采用归纳编码方法从讨论转录本中识别主题。主题分析显示,51.5%的PV照片与情商有关。他人发展和强大团队是44.3%的照片中呈现的主题。调查数据表明,所有受访者都认为PV是描述领导力学习的一种有价值的方法。访谈编码揭示了与情商和团队发展相关的主题。
PV方法是领导力APPE和选修课程中的一种有效教学工具。PV是一种可在各种体验式学习环境中使用的教学方法,以更好地促进药学专业学生的职业发展。