a Psychology and Communication Studies , University of Idaho , Moscow , ID , USA.
b Counseling and Psychological Services , Georgia State University , Atlanta , GA , USA.
Psychother Res. 2019 Jul;29(5):640-651. doi: 10.1080/10503307.2017.1413854. Epub 2017 Dec 13.
Given the psychological issues experienced by individuals high in perfectionistic concerns (maladaptive perfectionism), or a feeling as if one is never good enough, and discrepancies in the literature as to whether these individuals experience benefits from therapy, it is imperative that research examine whether perfectionism actually improves throughout therapy. The current study improves upon past research by examining changes in perfectionism (both perfectionistic concerns and strivings) throughout therapy, rather than simply measuring perfectionism at pre- and post-therapy. This study also investigates how these changes in perfectionism, if they exist, impact changes in psychological symptoms. In total, 153 clients at a psychology training clinic in which a general treatment paradigm was implemented completed the Short Almost Perfect Scale (SAPS; Rice et al., 2014) and Outcome Questionnaire (OQ-45.2; Lambert et al., 1996) prior to intake and sessions 1, 3, and 5. Multilevel modeling results revealed that there were significant improvements in perfectionistic concerns and symptoms although, as expected, no significant changes in perfectionistic strivings were observed. Additionally, there was a trend effect for changes in perfectionistic concerns being associated with changes in symptoms. Further, results of latent difference score analyses revealed that changes in symptoms throughout therapy preceded changes in perfectionistic concerns. This study uses multilevel modeling (MLM) and latent difference score analyses to assess changes in perfectionism throughout therapy, whether they are associated with changes in symptoms, and whether changes in perfectionism precede changes in symptoms, or vice versa. To date, there have been discrepancies in the literature as to whether perfectionism improves throughout therapy, and most of these have only measured perfectionism at pre- and post-therapy. This study is an improvement over past studies as it measures perfectionism throughout therapy which has implications for therapy work with perfectionistic clients.
鉴于高度关注完美主义(适应不良的完美主义)的个体所经历的心理问题,或者感觉自己永远不够好,以及文献中存在的关于这些个体是否从治疗中获益的差异,因此研究人员必须检查完美主义是否确实在治疗过程中得到改善。本研究通过检查治疗过程中完美主义(包括完美主义关注和努力)的变化,而不仅仅是在治疗前后测量完美主义,从而改进了过去的研究。本研究还调查了如果存在这些完美主义的变化,它们如何影响心理症状的变化。共有 153 名在实施一般治疗模式的心理学培训诊所接受治疗的患者完成了几乎完美量表(SAPS;Rice 等人,2014)和结果问卷(OQ-45.2;Lambert 等人,1996)在摄入和第 1、3 和 5 次治疗前。多层次建模结果表明,完美主义关注和症状都有显著改善,尽管正如预期的那样,完美主义努力没有观察到显著变化。此外,完美主义关注的变化与症状的变化呈趋势相关。此外,潜在差异得分分析的结果表明,治疗过程中症状的变化先于完美主义关注的变化。本研究使用多层次建模(MLM)和潜在差异得分分析来评估治疗过程中完美主义的变化,它们是否与症状的变化相关,以及完美主义的变化是否先于症状的变化,或者反之亦然。迄今为止,文献中对于完美主义是否在治疗过程中得到改善存在差异,而且大多数研究仅在治疗前后测量完美主义。本研究是对过去研究的改进,因为它在治疗过程中测量了完美主义,这对与完美主义患者进行治疗工作具有重要意义。