Shi Suming, Han Yuhang, Xu Lei, Li Jianfeng, Han Yuechen, Cai Jing, Wang Haibo
Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Head and Neck Surgery, Eye and ENT Hospital, Fudan University, Shanghai, China.
Department of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, Shandong Provincial Hospital Affiliated to Shandong University, Jinan, P. R. China.
World Neurosurg. 2018 Apr;112:e14-e22. doi: 10.1016/j.wneu.2017.11.167. Epub 2017 Dec 16.
Different degrees of neurotmesis of the peripheral facial nerve frequently are encountered in clinic, for which the epineurial neurorrhaphy is the preferred technique. However, because of the capability of self-restoration of nerves and the side effects of surgery, neurorrhaphy may not be an optimal choice for various degrees of neurotmesis. In this study, we explored the necessity of epineurial neurorrhaphy for different degrees of neurotmesis, in addition to investigating factors that impact neural functional recovery.
Rat models were divided into 6 groups: intact, noninjured controls; A, one-third cross-sectional facial nerve disconnected injury after epineurial neurorrhaphy; B, one-third cross-sectional facial nerve disconnected injury without epineurial neurorrhaphy; C, two-thirds cross-sectional facial nerve disconnected injury after epineurial neurorrhaphy; D, two-thirds cross-sectional facial nerve disconnected injury without epineurial neurorrhaphy; and E, two-thirds cross-sectional facial nerve disconnection followed by complete transection and neurorrhaphy. Facial functional recovery was assessed with the use of behavioral assessments and electrophysiologic tests. The morphologic changes of trunk of the facial nerve were analyzed by osmium-toluidine blue staining and immunofluorescence. The modification of central nervous system was evaluated by retrograde labeling and Nissl's staining of facial nerve nuclei.
Concerning morphologic and functional assessments, there were no statistically significant differences between one-third facial nerve disconnected injury with or without epineurial neurorrhaphy and the intact model. For two-thirds facial nerve disconnected injury, direct neurorrhaphy was superior to complete transection followed by neurorrhaphy. For two-thirds facial nerve disconnected injury, the nerves can largely self-restore in neural structure and function without the use of epineurial neurorrhaphy. For the facial nerve nuclei, the number of neurons decreased in the more than two-thirds nerve disconnected models, and models with two-thirds disconnection and without neurorrhaphy had the least number of neurons. For the distribution of neurons in different facial nerve subnuclei, both models with two-thirds nerve disconnection without neurorrhaphy and models with two-thirds nerve disconnection after complete transection and neurorrhaphy demonstrated disorganization of neurons, in which the latter was more serious.
For one-third disconnected facial nerve injury, there's no need to suture the nerve stump, although for residual one-third connected nerve injury, direct suture is preferable if permitted than pre-performing a complete transection to trim the stump. Residual one-third connected nerve fibers largely can self-restore. The results from this study indicate that neural functional defect may be attributed to the damage and misdirection of peripheral nerve fibers and central neurons.
临床上经常会遇到不同程度的周围面神经神经断裂,对此,神经外膜缝合术是首选技术。然而,由于神经的自我修复能力以及手术的副作用,神经缝合术可能并非各种程度神经断裂的最佳选择。在本研究中,我们探讨了不同程度神经断裂行神经外膜缝合术的必要性,此外还研究了影响神经功能恢复的因素。
将大鼠模型分为6组:完整无损的正常对照组;A组,面神经三分之一横断离断伤后行神经外膜缝合术;B组,面神经三分之一横断离断伤未行神经外膜缝合术;C组,面神经三分之二横断离断伤后行神经外膜缝合术;D组,面神经三分之二横断离断伤未行神经外膜缝合术;E组,面神经三分之二横断后再完全离断并进行神经缝合术。通过行为学评估和电生理测试评估面神经功能恢复情况。采用锇酸 - 甲苯胺蓝染色和免疫荧光分析面神经主干的形态学变化。通过逆行标记和面神经核的尼氏染色评估中枢神经系统的改变。
在形态学和功能评估方面,面神经三分之一横断离断伤行或未行神经外膜缝合术与完整模型之间无统计学显著差异。对于面神经三分之二横断离断伤,直接神经缝合术优于完全离断后再进行神经缝合术。对于面神经三分之二横断离断伤,神经在不进行神经外膜缝合术的情况下,在神经结构和功能上可在很大程度上自我修复。对于面神经核,超过三分之二神经离断的模型中神经元数量减少,三分之二离断且未行神经缝合术的模型中神经元数量最少。对于不同面神经亚核中神经元的分布,三分之二神经离断未行神经缝合术的模型和三分之二神经离断后完全离断并进行神经缝合术的模型均显示神经元排列紊乱,其中后者更严重。
对于面神经三分之一离断伤,无需缝合神经残端,不过对于残留三分之一相连的神经损伤,如果允许,直接缝合比预先完全离断修剪残端更可取。残留的三分之一相连神经纤维在很大程度上可自我修复。本研究结果表明,神经功能缺陷可能归因于周围神经纤维和中枢神经元的损伤及错向。