Bithoney W G, McJunkin J, Michalek J, Egan H, Snyder J, Munier A
Comprehensive Child Health Program, Children's Hospital, Boston, MA 02115.
J Dev Behav Pediatr. 1989 Feb;10(1):27-31.
Failure-to-thrive (FTT) is categorized as organic (OFTT) or nonorganic (NFTT). Traditionally, it has been taught that children with OFTT are unable to grow well in spite of adequate care (calories, nurturance, medical supervision), whereas NFTT children will grow well when given adequate care. We undertook this study to determine whether NFTT and OFTT children could grow at similar rates when treated by a specialized multidisciplinary team that provided concrete, individualized therapies including psychosocial support, medical care, and hypercaloric diets. Eighty-six children were enrolled on referral to our outpatient FTT consultative clinic; 64 had NFTT and 22 had OFTT. Growth quotient analysis was used to determine growth outcomes over a 6-month follow-up period. Growth at a rate paralleling the growth curve produces a GQ equal to 1. Growth 2 times as rapid as expected gives a GQ = 2. Children in both groups grew extremely well. For NFTT, GQ = 1.67 +/- 0.56 (SD); for OFTT, GQ = 1.81 +/- 0.37 (SD), p = NS. OFTT children grew just as well as NFTT children when given adequate calories for catch-up growth. Our data indicate that weight gain alone cannot reliably differentiate OFTT from NFTT, as has been traditionally taught. They suggest that we make every attempt to maximize caloric intake in FTT children. They also suggest that a multidisciplinary team consisting of a pediatrician, child psychiatrist, nutritionist, nurse clinician, and social worker may be successful in managing FTT children.
生长发育迟缓(FTT)分为器质性(OFTT)和非器质性(NFTT)。传统观点认为,尽管给予了足够的照料(热量、养育、医疗监督),患有OFTT的儿童仍无法良好生长,而患有NFTT的儿童在给予足够照料时会生长良好。我们开展这项研究是为了确定,当由一个提供具体、个性化治疗(包括心理社会支持、医疗护理和高热量饮食)的专业多学科团队进行治疗时,NFTT和OFTT儿童是否能以相似的速度生长。86名儿童被转诊至我们的门诊FTT咨询诊所;64名患有NFTT,22名患有OFTT。通过生长商分析来确定6个月随访期内的生长结果。生长速度与生长曲线平行时,生长商等于1。生长速度比预期快两倍时,生长商 = 2。两组儿童生长情况都非常好。对于NFTT,生长商 = 1.67 +/- 0.56(标准差);对于OFTT,生长商 = 1.81 +/- 0.37(标准差),p值无统计学意义。当给予足够热量以实现追赶生长时,OFTT儿童的生长情况与NFTT儿童一样好。我们的数据表明,仅靠体重增加并不能像传统观点所认为的那样可靠地区分OFTT和NFTT。数据还表明,我们应尽一切努力使FTT儿童的热量摄入最大化。数据还表明,由儿科医生、儿童精神科医生、营养师、护士临床医生和社会工作者组成的多学科团队可能成功管理FTT儿童。