Maruthy Santosh, Feng Yongqiang, Max Ludo
All India Institute of Speech and Hearing, India.
Institute of Acoustics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, China.
Lang Speech. 2018 Mar;61(1):31-42. doi: 10.1177/0023830917695853. Epub 2017 Mar 9.
A longstanding hypothesis about the sensorimotor mechanisms underlying stuttering suggests that stuttered speech dysfluencies result from a lack of coarticulation. Formant-based measures of either the stuttered or fluent speech of children and adults who stutter have generally failed to obtain compelling evidence in support of the hypothesis that these individuals differ in the timing or degree of coarticulation. Here, we used a sensitive acoustic technique-spectral coefficient analyses-that allowed us to compare stuttering and nonstuttering speakers with regard to vowel-dependent anticipatory influences as early as the onset burst of a preceding voiceless stop consonant. Eight adults who stutter and eight matched adults who do not stutter produced CVC words, and the first four spectral coefficients were calculated for one analysis window centered on the burst of C and two subsequent windows covering the beginning of the aspiration phase. Findings confirmed that the combined use of four spectral coefficients is an effective method for detecting the anticipatory influence of a vowel on the initial burst of a preceding voiceless stop consonant. However, the observed patterns of anticipatory coarticulation showed no statistically significant differences, or trends toward such differences, between the stuttering and nonstuttering groups. Combining the present results for fluent speech in one given phonetic context with prior findings from both stuttered and fluent speech in a variety of other contexts, we conclude that there is currently no support for the hypothesis that the fluent speech of individuals who stutter is characterized by limited coarticulation.
一个关于口吃背后感觉运动机制的长期假设认为,口吃性言语不流畅是由于协同发音不足所致。基于共振峰对口吃儿童和成人的口吃或流畅言语进行测量,总体上未能获得令人信服的证据来支持这一假设,即这些个体在协同发音的时间或程度上存在差异。在此,我们使用了一种灵敏的声学技术——频谱系数分析,这使我们能够早在前一个清塞音的爆发起始点,就口吃者和非口吃者在元音依赖的预期影响方面进行比较。八名口吃成人和八名匹配的非口吃成人说出了辅音-元音-辅音(CVC)单词,并针对以C音爆发为中心的一个分析窗口以及随后覆盖送气阶段开始部分的两个窗口,计算了前四个频谱系数。研究结果证实,综合使用四个频谱系数是检测元音对前一个清塞音初始爆发的预期影响的有效方法。然而,在口吃组和非口吃组之间,观察到的预期协同发音模式没有显示出统计学上的显著差异,也没有这种差异的趋势。将在一个特定语音语境中流畅言语的当前结果与在各种其他语境中口吃和流畅言语的先前研究结果相结合,我们得出结论,目前没有证据支持这一假设,即口吃者的流畅言语具有有限协同发音的特征。