Zamboni Lucila M
Rockefeller College of Public Affairs and Policy,University at Albany - State University of New York.
Disaster Med Public Health Prep. 2017 Dec;11(6):756-763. doi: 10.1017/dmp.2017.22.
A systematic literature review on quantitative methods to assess community resilience was conducted following Institute of Medicine and Patient-Centered Outcomes Research Institute standards. Community resilience is the ability of a community to bounce back or return to normal after a disaster strikes, yet there is no agreement on what this actually means. All studies reviewed addressed natural disasters, but the methodological approaches can be applied to technological disasters, epidemics, and terrorist attacks. Theoretical frameworks consider the association between vulnerability, resilience, and preparedness, yet these associations vary across frameworks. Because of this complexity, indexes based on composite indicators are the predominant methodological tool used to assess community resilience. Indexes identify similar dimensions but observe resilience at both the individual and geographical levels, reflecting a lack of agreement on what constitutes a community. A consistent, cross-disciplinary metric for community resilience would allow for identifying areas to apply short-term versus long-term interventions. A comparable metric for assessing geographic units in multiple levels and dimensions is an opportunity to identify regional strengths and weaknesses, develop timely targeted policy interventions, improve policy evaluation instruments, and grant allocation formulas design. (Disaster Med Public Health Preparedness. 2017;11:756-763).
按照美国医学研究所和以患者为中心的结果研究机构的标准,对评估社区恢复力的定量方法进行了系统的文献综述。社区恢复力是指社区在遭受灾难后恢复或回归正常的能力,但对于其实际含义尚无共识。所有纳入综述的研究均涉及自然灾害,但这些方法也可应用于技术灾难、流行病和恐怖袭击。理论框架考虑了脆弱性、恢复力和备灾之间的关联,但这些关联在不同框架中有所不同。由于这种复杂性,基于综合指标的指数是评估社区恢复力的主要方法工具。指数确定了相似的维度,但在个体和地理层面观察恢复力,这反映出对于社区的构成缺乏共识。一个一致的、跨学科的社区恢复力衡量标准将有助于确定应用短期和长期干预措施的领域。一个用于在多个层面和维度评估地理单元的可比衡量标准,为识别区域优势和劣势、制定及时的针对性政策干预措施、改进政策评估工具以及设计拨款分配公式提供了契机。(《灾难医学与公共卫生防范》。2017年;11:756 - 763)