From the Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Duke University Health System, Durham, NC.
J Am Acad Orthop Surg. 2018 Feb 1;26(3):e62-e67. doi: 10.5435/JAAOS-D-16-00701.
Most orthopaedic surgery residents elect to pursue additional subspecialty training; however, factors influencing the choice of subspecialty and the ways that these factors change during training are not well understood. The aim of this investigation was to determine, on the basis of a trainee's postgraduate year (PGY), whether variability exists in factors valued when choosing a specific subspecialty.
We emailed an online survey (intended for distribution to current trainees) to a list of orthopaedic surgery residency program coordinators in the United States. The survey queried demographic information, PGY level, and the importance of 14 discrete factors in the selection of fellowship specialty according to a Likert scale rating from 1 to 4.
There were 359 respondents representing an even distribution of PGY levels. Junior trainees assigned greater relative value to geographic location, on-call responsibilities, financial compensation, and the tradition of the residency program, whereas senior trainees assigned greater relative value to variety of cases and intellectual stimulation (all P < 0.05).
The differences seen in factors valued based on trainee experience may highlight the relative importance of greater exposure to the breadth of orthopaedic surgical practice during training and increasing awareness of clinical competencies and responsibilities.
When deciding on orthopaedic subspecialty choice, junior trainees value lifestyle factors relatively more than do senior trainees, whereas senior trainees value case variety and stimulation relatively more than junior trainees do.
大多数骨科住院医师选择接受额外的亚专业培训;然而,影响选择亚专业的因素以及这些因素在培训过程中的变化方式尚不清楚。本研究旨在根据住院医师的研究生年级(PGY),确定在选择特定亚专业时,有价值的因素是否存在差异。
我们向美国骨科住院医师培训计划协调员的名单发送了一份在线调查(旨在分发给现任住院医师)。该调查询问了人口统计学信息、PGY 水平,以及根据李克特量表评分(1-4 分)对选择 fellowship 专业的 14 个离散因素的重要性。
共有 359 名受访者,PGY 水平分布均匀。初级受训者赋予地理位置、值班职责、经济补偿和住院医师项目传统更高的相对价值,而高级受训者赋予病例多样性和智力刺激更高的相对价值(均 P < 0.05)。
根据受训者经验而产生的有价值因素的差异,可能突出了在培训过程中更多地接触广泛的骨科手术实践以及提高对临床能力和责任的认识的相对重要性。
在决定选择骨科亚专业时,初级受训者相对更看重生活方式因素,而高级受训者相对更看重病例多样性和刺激。