Adnan Samira, Lone Maham M, Khan Farhan R, Hussain Syeda M, Nagi Sana E
Operative Dentistry, Jinnah Sindh Medical University, Karachi, Pakistan.
Operative Dentistry, Aga Khan University Hospital, Karachi, Pakistan.
Dent Traumatol. 2018 Apr;34(2):59-70. doi: 10.1111/edt.12382. Epub 2018 Feb 6.
BACKGROUND/AIMS: A wide variety of materials has been researched for their use as potential storage media for avulsed teeth, but it is essential to recognize the medium most recommended for improvement of the prognosis of avulsed teeth. The aim of this systematic review was to identify the most recommended medium to store and transport avulsed teeth based on the survival of periodontal ligament (PDL) cells as determined by in vitro studies.
Only laboratory-based experimental studies on PDL cells found on adult permanent teeth were included. Data were collected using PubMed, CINAHL plus (EBSCO host), and the Cochrane Library, along with Google Scholar and a hand search. The key terms employed were permutations of [avulsed permanent teeth* OR dental avulsion* OR knocked out teeth*] AND [storage media* OR transport media* OR biological transport* OR PDL cell viability* OR PDL cell survival*]. A customized data extraction pro forma was used to extract the data and to evaluate the quality and risk of bias.
The initial search yielded 978 articles, but only 67 were selected. Milk was the most recommended individual medium followed by Hank's balanced salt solution. Among natural products other than milk, propolis and coconut water were most frequently recommended. Recommendations were based on maintenance of PDL cell viability followed by ease of availability, low cost, and long shelf life.
Natural products are more effective in maintaining the PDL cell viability compared to synthetic products. Some storage media recommendations were also based upon practical aspects. Although natural products other than milk have more recommendations as a group, milk is the most recommended storage medium individually, based not only on PDL cell viability, but also practical considerations.
背景/目的:人们已经对各种各样的材料作为脱位牙潜在储存介质的用途进行了研究,但必须确定最推荐用于改善脱位牙预后的介质。本系统评价的目的是根据体外研究确定的牙周膜(PDL)细胞存活率,找出最推荐的储存和运输脱位牙的介质。
仅纳入基于实验室的关于成人恒牙上PDL细胞的实验研究。使用PubMed、CINAHL plus(EBSCO主机)、Cochrane图书馆以及谷歌学术搜索和手工检索收集数据。使用的关键词是[脱位恒牙或牙脱位或 knocked out teeth*]与[储存介质或运输介质或生物运输或PDL细胞活力或PDL细胞存活*]的排列组合。使用定制的数据提取表格来提取数据并评估质量和偏倚风险。
初步搜索得到978篇文章,但仅选择了67篇。牛奶是最推荐的单一介质,其次是汉克平衡盐溶液。在除牛奶以外的天然产物中,蜂胶和椰子水最常被推荐。推荐基于PDL细胞活力的维持,其次是易于获取、低成本和长保质期。
与合成产品相比,天然产物在维持PDL细胞活力方面更有效。一些储存介质的推荐也基于实际方面。尽管除牛奶以外的天然产物作为一个群体有更多的推荐,但牛奶是最推荐的单一储存介质,这不仅基于PDL细胞活力,也基于实际考虑。