Jaroma M, Pakarinen L, Nuutinen J
Kuopio University Central Hospital, Department of Otolaryngology and Phoniatrics, Finland.
Acta Otolaryngol. 1989 Mar-Apr;107(3-4):296-9. doi: 10.3109/00016488909127512.
Combined surgical and conservative therapy (voice therapy, treatment of infections, allergy, oesophageal reflux, and psychogenic stress) has been used in the treatment of non-specific vocal cord granuloma. Such tumors have a great tendency to recur. The 41 patients with vocal cord granuloma in our study (4 women, 37 men, mean age 56 years) were treated at our hospital during 1980-1986. Nine patients were healed with conservative treatment, 32 were treated by laryngomicrosurgery under general anesthesia and jet-ventilation. The latter group was divided into three treatment groups; 8 of these patients were treated with cryotherapy, 9 with postoperative steroids (Prednisolone 40 mg/day in decreasing doses) and antibiotics, and 15 only with microsurgery. At some phase in their treatment 41% of the patients were able to participate in voice therapy. The most recurrences were found in the group treated with cryotherapy, 2.7 rec./pat.; 1.8 rec./pat. were found in the group that underwent surgery, and 1.7 rec./pat. among the patients treated with steroid-antibiotics. In all three groups, some patients experienced recurrences. In the cryotherapy group, however, recurrent granulomas were large and required reoperation, while those in patients treated with steroid-antibiotics were small and could be cured using conservative therapy. If granuloma does not disturb the voice, cause respiratory obstruction or demand histopathological diagnosis, surgery is contraindicated. Cryotherapy does not help traditional surgery, while steroid-antibiotics administered postoperatively seem to help the healing process.
手术与保守治疗(嗓音治疗、感染治疗、过敏治疗、食管反流治疗及心理应激治疗)相结合已被用于非特异性声带肉芽肿的治疗。此类肿瘤极易复发。我们研究中的41例声带肉芽肿患者(4例女性,37例男性,平均年龄56岁)于1980年至1986年在我院接受治疗。9例患者经保守治疗痊愈,32例在全身麻醉和喷射通气下行喉显微手术治疗。后一组又分为三个治疗组;其中8例患者接受冷冻治疗,9例接受术后类固醇(泼尼松龙40mg/天,剂量递减)及抗生素治疗,15例仅接受显微手术治疗。在治疗的某个阶段,41%的患者能够参与嗓音治疗。冷冻治疗组复发率最高,为2.7次/患者;手术组为1.8次/患者,类固醇-抗生素治疗组为1.7次/患者。所有三组中均有部分患者复发。然而,冷冻治疗组复发的肉芽肿较大,需要再次手术,而类固醇-抗生素治疗组患者复发的肉芽肿较小,可采用保守治疗治愈。如果肉芽肿不影响嗓音、不引起呼吸阻塞或无需组织病理学诊断,则禁忌手术。冷冻治疗对传统手术并无帮助,而术后使用类固醇-抗生素似乎有助于愈合过程。