Wingenbach Tanja S H, Ashwin Chris, Brosnan Mark
Department of Psychology, University of Bath, Bath, Somerset, United Kingdom.
PLoS One. 2018 Jan 2;13(1):e0190634. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0190634. eCollection 2018.
There has been much research on sex differences in the ability to recognise facial expressions of emotions, with results generally showing a female advantage in reading emotional expressions from the face. However, most of the research to date has used static images and/or 'extreme' examples of facial expressions. Therefore, little is known about how expression intensity and dynamic stimuli might affect the commonly reported female advantage in facial emotion recognition. The current study investigated sex differences in accuracy of response (Hu; unbiased hit rates) and response latencies for emotion recognition using short video stimuli (1sec) of 10 different facial emotion expressions (anger, disgust, fear, sadness, surprise, happiness, contempt, pride, embarrassment, neutral) across three variations in the intensity of the emotional expression (low, intermediate, high) in an adolescent and adult sample (N = 111; 51 male, 60 female) aged between 16 and 45 (M = 22.2, SD = 5.7). Overall, females showed more accurate facial emotion recognition compared to males and were faster in correctly recognising facial emotions. The female advantage in reading expressions from the faces of others was unaffected by expression intensity levels and emotion categories used in the study. The effects were specific to recognition of emotions, as males and females did not differ in the recognition of neutral faces. Together, the results showed a robust sex difference favouring females in facial emotion recognition using video stimuli of a wide range of emotions and expression intensity variations.
关于识别面部表情情感能力的性别差异已有大量研究,结果总体表明女性在从面部读取情感表达方面具有优势。然而,迄今为止的大多数研究都使用了静态图像和/或面部表情的“极端”示例。因此,对于表情强度和动态刺激如何影响普遍报道的女性在面部情感识别中的优势,人们知之甚少。本研究调查了在青少年和成人样本(N = 111;51名男性,60名女性)中,年龄在16至45岁之间(M = 22.2,SD = 5.7),使用10种不同面部情感表情(愤怒、厌恶、恐惧、悲伤、惊讶、快乐、轻蔑、自豪、尴尬、中性)的短视频刺激(1秒),在情感表达强度的三种变化(低、中、高)下,情感识别的反应准确性(Hu;无偏命中率)和反应潜伏期的性别差异。总体而言,与男性相比,女性表现出更准确的面部情感识别,并且在正确识别面部情感方面更快。女性从他人面部读取表情的优势不受研究中使用的表情强度水平和情感类别的影响。这些影响特定于情感识别,因为男性和女性在识别中性面孔方面没有差异。总之,结果表明在使用各种情感和表情强度变化的视频刺激进行面部情感识别时,存在有利于女性的显著性别差异。