Tang Junqing, Heinimann Hans Rudolf
ETH Zurich, Future Resilient Systems, Singapore-ETH Centre, Singapore, Singapore.
PLoS One. 2018 Jan 2;13(1):e0190616. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0190616. eCollection 2018.
Traffic congestion brings not only delay and inconvenience, but other associated national concerns, such as greenhouse gases, air pollutants, road safety issues and risks. Identification, measurement, tracking, and control of urban recurrent congestion are vital for building a livable and smart community. A considerable amount of works has made contributions to tackle the problem. Several methods, such as time-based approaches and level of service, can be effective for characterizing congestion on urban streets. However, studies with systemic perspectives have been minor in congestion quantification. Resilience, on the other hand, is an emerging concept that focuses on comprehensive systemic performance and characterizes the ability of a system to cope with disturbance and to recover its functionality. In this paper, we symbolized recurrent congestion as internal disturbance and proposed a modified metric inspired by the well-applied "R4" resilience-triangle framework. We constructed the metric with generic dimensions from both resilience engineering and transport science to quantify recurrent congestion based on spatial-temporal traffic patterns and made the comparison with other two approaches in freeway and signal-controlled arterial cases. Results showed that the metric can effectively capture congestion patterns in the study area and provides a quantitative benchmark for comparison. Also, it suggested not only a good comparative performance in measuring strength of proposed metric, but also its capability of considering the discharging process in congestion. The sensitivity tests showed that proposed metric possesses robustness against parameter perturbation in Robustness Range (RR), but the number of identified congestion patterns can be influenced by the existence of ϵ. In addition, the Elasticity Threshold (ET) and the spatial dimension of cell-based platform differ the congestion results significantly on both the detected number and intensity. By tackling this conventional problem with emerging concept, our metric provides a systemic alternative approach and enriches the toolbox for congestion assessment. Future work will be conducted on a larger scale with multiplex scenarios in various traffic conditions.
交通拥堵不仅带来延误和不便,还引发了其他相关的国家问题,如温室气体、空气污染物、道路安全问题及风险。识别、测量、跟踪和控制城市经常性拥堵对于建设宜居和智能社区至关重要。大量工作已为解决该问题做出了贡献。几种方法,如基于时间的方法和服务水平,可有效表征城市街道的拥堵情况。然而,从系统视角进行的拥堵量化研究较少。另一方面,弹性是一个新兴概念,关注综合系统性能,并表征系统应对干扰和恢复其功能的能力。在本文中,我们将经常性拥堵象征为内部干扰,并提出了一种受广泛应用的“R4”弹性三角框架启发的改进指标。我们从弹性工程和交通科学的通用维度构建该指标,以基于时空交通模式量化经常性拥堵,并在高速公路和信号控制干道案例中与其他两种方法进行比较。结果表明,该指标能有效捕捉研究区域的拥堵模式,并提供了一个定量比较基准。此外,它不仅在测量所提指标强度方面具有良好的比较性能,还具备考虑拥堵排放过程的能力。敏感性测试表明,所提指标在稳健范围(RR)内对参数扰动具有鲁棒性,但识别出的拥堵模式数量可能受ε存在的影响。此外,弹性阈值(ET)和基于单元格平台的空间维度在检测到的数量和强度方面对拥堵结果有显著差异。通过用新兴概念解决这一传统问题,我们的指标提供了一种系统的替代方法,并丰富了拥堵评估工具箱。未来工作将在更大规模上针对各种交通条件下的多重场景展开。