Numajiri Toshiaki, Morita Daiki, Nakamura Hiroko, Tsujiko Shoko, Yamochi Ryo, Sowa Yoshihiro, Toyoda Kenichiro, Tsujikawa Takahiro, Arai Akihito, Yasuda Makoto, Hirano Shigeru
Department Head and Associate Professor, Department of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, Kyoto Prefectural University of Medicine, Kyoto, Japan.
Resident, Department of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, Kyoto Prefectural University of Medicine, Kyoto, Japan.
J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2018 Jun;76(6):1361-1369. doi: 10.1016/j.joms.2017.11.042. Epub 2017 Dec 12.
Computer-assisted design (CAD) and computer-aided manufacturing (CAM) techniques are in widespread use for maxillofacial reconstruction. However, CAD/CAM surgical guides are commercially available only in limited areas. To use this technology in areas where these commercial guides are not available, the authors developed a CAD/CAM technique in which all processes are performed by the surgeon (in-house approach). The authors describe their experience and the characteristics of their in-house CAD/CAM reconstruction of the maxilla.
This was a retrospective study of maxillary reconstruction with a free osteocutaneous flap. Free CAD software was used for virtual surgery and to design the cutting guides (maxilla and fibula), which were printed by a 3-dimensional printer. After the model surgery and pre-bending of the titanium plates, the actual reconstructions were performed. The authors compared the clinical information, preoperative plan, and postoperative reconstruction data. The reconstruction was judged as accurate if more than 80% of the reconstructed points were within a deviation of 2 mm.
Although on-site adjustment was necessary in particular cases, all 4 reconstructions were judged as accurate. In total, 3 days were needed before the surgery for planning, printing, and pre-bending of plates. The average ischemic time was 134 minutes (flap suturing and bone fixation, 70 minutes; vascular anastomoses, 64 minutes). The mean deviation after reconstruction was 0.44 mm (standard deviation, 0.97). The deviations were 67.8% for 1 mm, 93.8% for 2 mm, and 98.6% for 3 mm. The disadvantages of the regular use of CAD/CAM reconstruction are the intraoperative changes in defect size and local tissue scarring.
Good accuracy was obtained for CAD/CAM-guided reconstructions based on an in-house approach. The theoretical advantage of computer simulation contributes to the accuracy. An in-house approach could be an option for maxillary reconstruction.
计算机辅助设计(CAD)和计算机辅助制造(CAM)技术在颌面重建中广泛应用。然而,CAD/CAM手术导板仅在有限区域有商业供应。为了在这些商业导板无法获取的地区使用该技术,作者开发了一种CAD/CAM技术,其中所有流程均由外科医生完成(内部方法)。作者描述了他们在使用内部CAD/CAM进行上颌骨重建方面的经验及特点。
这是一项关于使用游离骨皮瓣进行上颌骨重建的回顾性研究。使用免费CAD软件进行虚拟手术并设计切割导板(上颌骨和腓骨),这些导板由三维打印机打印。在模型手术和钛板预弯后,进行实际重建。作者比较了临床信息、术前计划和术后重建数据。如果超过80%的重建点偏差在2毫米以内,则判定重建准确。
尽管在特定情况下需要现场调整,但所有4例重建均被判定为准确。术前规划、打印和钛板预弯总共需要3天时间。平均缺血时间为134分钟(皮瓣缝合和骨固定,70分钟;血管吻合,64分钟)。重建后的平均偏差为0.44毫米(标准差,0.97)。偏差在1毫米以内的占67.8%,在2毫米以内的占93.8%,在3毫米以内的占98.6%。常规使用CAD/CAM重建的缺点是缺损大小的术中变化和局部组织瘢痕形成。
基于内部方法的CAD/CAM引导下的重建获得了良好的准确性。计算机模拟的理论优势有助于提高准确性。内部方法可作为上颌骨重建的一种选择。