Martin D F, Baker C L, Curl W W, Andrews J R, Robie D B, Haas A F
Hughston Orthopaedic Clinic, PC, Columbus, Georgia 31995.
Am J Sports Med. 1989 Jan-Feb;17(1):16-23; discussion 23. doi: 10.1177/036354658901700103.
Ankle arthroscopy has become an accepted procedure for the treatment of various intraarticular disorders. More than 100 ankle arthroscopies have been performed at our institution since 1983. To better define the role of arthroscopic surgery in the treatment of ankle disorders, we evaluated the preoperative examination and indications, operative data, and radiographs of those patients with a minimum of 1 year of followup. Fifty-eight ankles in 57 patients were identified; their average follow-up period was 25 months (range, 12 to 49 months). Preoperative diagnoses were synovitis (26), transchondral defects of the talus (17), degenerative joint disease (8), and osteophytes or loose bodies (7). Subjective results were good or excellent in 64% of cases. The best overall results were achieved in patients with synovitis (77%) and transchondral defects of the talus (71%). Degenerative joint disease patients did not do well. They had only 12% good or excellent results and a 43% rate of subsequent fusion. Complications included superficial and deep infections, temporary and permanent paresthesias, and hemarthroses; the overall complication rate was 15%. In conclusion, operative ankle arthroscopy can be useful in selected patients. It is an effective surgical procedure in patients with synovitis and transchondral defects of the talus. The benefits and long-term results are less predictable with loose bodies and impinging osteophytes; the results are poor with degenerative joint disease. There appears to be a significant risk of complication with ankle arthroscopy; however, with proper indications, a thorough knowledge of anatomical landmarks, and meticulous technique, good results can be obtained.
踝关节镜检查已成为治疗各种关节内疾病的一种公认的手术方法。自1983年以来,我们机构已进行了100多例踝关节镜检查。为了更好地确定关节镜手术在踝关节疾病治疗中的作用,我们评估了那些至少随访1年的患者的术前检查、适应证、手术数据和X线片。共确定了57例患者的58个踝关节;平均随访期为25个月(范围为12至49个月)。术前诊断为滑膜炎(26例)、距骨软骨下缺损(17例)、退行性关节病(8例)以及骨赘或游离体(7例)。64%的病例主观结果为良好或优秀。滑膜炎患者(77%)和距骨软骨下缺损患者(71%)总体结果最佳。退行性关节病患者效果不佳。他们仅有12%的良好或优秀结果,后续融合率为43%。并发症包括表浅和深部感染、暂时和永久性感觉异常以及关节积血;总体并发症发生率为15%。总之,手术踝关节镜检查对部分患者可能有用。它是治疗滑膜炎和距骨软骨下缺损患者的有效手术方法。对于游离体和撞击性骨赘,其益处和长期结果较难预测;对于退行性关节病,结果较差。踝关节镜检查似乎有显著的并发症风险;然而,有适当的适应证、对解剖标志的透彻了解以及细致的技术操作,就能获得良好的结果。