Bianchi Simone, Cahalan Christine, Hale Sophie, Gibbons James Michael
School of Environment Natural Resources and Geography Bangor University Bangor Gwynedd UK.
Northern Research Station Forest Research Roslin Midlothian UK.
Ecol Evol. 2017 Nov 1;7(24):10556-10566. doi: 10.1002/ece3.3567. eCollection 2017 Dec.
Hemispherical photography (HP), implemented with cameras equipped with "fisheye" lenses, is a widely used method for describing forest canopies and light regimes. A promising technological advance is the availability of low-cost fisheye lenses for smartphone cameras. However, smartphone camera sensors cannot record a full hemisphere. We investigate whether smartphone HP is a cheaper and faster but still adequate operational alternative to traditional cameras for describing forest canopies and light regimes. We collected hemispherical pictures with both smartphone and traditional cameras in 223 forest sample points, across different overstory species and canopy densities. The smartphone image acquisition followed a faster and simpler protocol than that for the traditional camera. We automatically thresholded all images. We processed the traditional camera images for Canopy Openness (CO) and Site Factor estimation. For smartphone images, we took two pictures with different orientations per point and used two processing protocols: (i) we estimated and averaged total canopy gap from the two single pictures, and (ii) merging the two pictures together, we formed images closer to full hemispheres and estimated from them CO and Site Factors. We compared the same parameters obtained from different cameras and estimated generalized linear mixed models (GLMMs) between them. Total canopy gap estimated from the first processing protocol for smartphone pictures was on average significantly higher than CO estimated from traditional camera images, although with a consistent bias. Canopy Openness and Site Factors estimated from merged smartphone pictures of the second processing protocol were on average significantly higher than those from traditional cameras images, although with relatively little absolute differences and scatter. Smartphone HP is an acceptable alternative to HP using traditional cameras, providing similar results with a faster and cheaper methodology. Smartphone outputs can be directly used as they are for ecological studies, or converted with specific models for a better comparison to traditional cameras.
半球形摄影(HP)通过配备“鱼眼”镜头的相机来实现,是一种广泛用于描述森林冠层和光照状况的方法。一项有前景的技术进步是智能手机相机可使用低成本的鱼眼镜头。然而,智能手机相机传感器无法记录完整的半球形。我们研究智能手机半球形摄影对于描述森林冠层和光照状况而言,是否是一种比传统相机更便宜、更快速且仍足够适用的操作替代方法。我们在223个森林采样点使用智能手机和传统相机收集了半球形图片,这些采样点涵盖不同的上层树种和冠层密度。智能手机图像采集遵循的协议比传统相机更快、更简单。我们对所有图像进行自动阈值处理。我们处理传统相机图像以估算冠层开阔度(CO)和立地因子。对于智能手机图像,我们每个采样点拍摄两张不同方向的照片,并使用两种处理协议:(i)我们从两张单张照片中估算并平均总冠层间隙,(ii)将两张照片合并在一起,形成更接近完整半球形的图像,并据此估算CO和立地因子。我们比较了不同相机获得的相同参数,并估算了它们之间的广义线性混合模型(GLMMs)。从智能手机照片的第一种处理协议估算的总冠层间隙平均显著高于从传统相机图像估算的CO,尽管存在一致的偏差。从第二种处理协议的合并智能手机照片估算的冠层开阔度和立地因子平均显著高于传统相机图像的估算值,尽管绝对差异和离散度相对较小。智能手机半球形摄影是使用传统相机进行半球形摄影的可接受替代方法,以更快、更便宜的方法提供类似结果。智能手机的输出结果可直接用于生态研究,或通过特定模型进行转换,以便更好地与传统相机进行比较。