Suarez-Escobar Marian, Rendon-Velez Elizabeth
a Design Engineering Research Group (GRID), Department of Product Design Engineering , Universidad EAFIT , Medellin , Colombia.
Disabil Rehabil Assist Technol. 2018 Oct;13(7):683-703. doi: 10.1080/17483107.2018.1425746. Epub 2018 Jan 15.
This article aims to clarify the current state-of-the-art of robotic/mechanical devices for post-stroke thumb rehabilitation as well as the anatomical characteristics and motions of the thumb that are crucial for the development of any device that aims to support its motion.
A systematic literature search was conducted to identify robotic/mechanical devices for post-stroke thumb rehabilitation. Specific electronic databases and well-defined search terms and inclusion/exclusion criteria were used for such purpose. A reasoning model was devised to support the structured abstraction of relevant data from the literature of interest.
Following the main search and after removing duplicated and other non-relevant studies, 68 articles (corresponding to 32 devices) were left for further examination. These articles were analyzed to extract data relative to (i) the motions assisted/permitted - either actively or passively - by the device per anatomical joint of the thumb and (ii) mechanical-related aspects (i.e., architecture, connections to thumb, other fingers supported, adjustability to different hand sizes, actuators - type, quantity, location, power transmission and motion trajectory).
Most articles describe preliminary design and testing of prototypes, rather than the thorough evaluation of commercially ready devices. Defining appropriate kinematic models of the thumb upon which to design such devices still remains a challenging and unresolved task. Further research is needed before these devices can actually be implemented in clinical environments to serve their intended purpose of complementing the labour of therapists by facilitating intensive treatment with precise and repeatable exercises. Implications for Rehabilitation Post-stroke functional disability of the hand, and particularly of the thumb, significantly affects the capability to perform activities of daily living, threatening the independence and quality of life of the stroke survivors. The latest studies show that a high-dose intensive therapy (in terms of frequency, duration and intensity/effort) is the key to effectively modify neural organization and recover the motor skills that were lost after a stroke. Conventional therapy based on manual interaction with physical therapists makes the procedure labour intensive and increases the costs. Robotic/mechanical devices hold promise for complementing conventional post-stroke therapy. Specifically, these devices can provide reliable and accurate therapy for long periods of time without the associated fatigue. Also, they can be used as a means to assess patients? performance and progress in an objective and consistent manner. The full potential of robot-assisted therapy is still to be unveiled. Further exploration will surely lead to devices that can be well accepted equally by therapists and patients and that can be useful both in clinical and home-based rehabilitation practice such that motor recovery of the hand becomes a common outcome in stroke survivors. This overview provides the reader, possibly a designer of such a device, with a complete overview of the state-of-the-art of robotic/mechanical devices consisting of or including features for the rehabilitation of the thumb. Also, we clarify the anatomical characteristics and motions of the thumb that are crucial for the development of any device that aims to support its motion. Hopefully, this?combined with the outlined opportunities for further research?leads to the improvement of current devices and the development of new technology and knowledge in the field.
本文旨在阐明用于中风后拇指康复的机器人/机械设备的当前技术水平,以及拇指的解剖学特征和运动,这些对于旨在支持其运动的任何设备的开发至关重要。
进行了系统的文献检索,以识别用于中风后拇指康复的机器人/机械设备。为此使用了特定的电子数据库以及明确的检索词和纳入/排除标准。设计了一个推理模型,以支持从相关文献中结构化提取相关数据。
在主要检索之后,去除重复和其他不相关的研究后,留下68篇文章(对应32种设备)进行进一步审查。对这些文章进行分析,以提取与以下方面相关的数据:(i)设备对拇指每个解剖关节主动或被动辅助/允许的运动;(ii)机械相关方面(即结构、与拇指的连接、支持的其他手指、对不同手尺寸的可调节性、致动器——类型、数量、位置、动力传输和运动轨迹)。
大多数文章描述的是原型的初步设计和测试,而不是对商业可用设备的全面评估。定义适合设计此类设备的拇指运动学模型仍然是一项具有挑战性且未解决的任务。在这些设备能够实际应用于临床环境以实现其通过精确且可重复的练习促进强化治疗来补充治疗师工作的预期目的之前,还需要进一步研究。对康复的意义中风后手功能障碍,尤其是拇指功能障碍,会显著影响日常生活活动能力,威胁中风幸存者的独立性和生活质量。最新研究表明,高剂量强化治疗(在频率、持续时间和强度/努力方面)是有效改变神经组织并恢复中风后丧失的运动技能的关键。基于与物理治疗师手动交互的传统治疗劳动强度大且成本高。机器人/机械设备有望补充传统的中风后治疗。具体而言,这些设备可以长时间提供可靠且准确的治疗而不会产生相关疲劳。此外,它们可以用作客观且一致地评估患者表现和进展的手段。机器人辅助治疗的全部潜力仍有待揭示。进一步探索肯定会带来能被治疗师和患者同样欣然接受、在临床和家庭康复实践中都有用的设备,从而使手部运动恢复成为中风幸存者的常见结果。本综述为读者(可能是此类设备的设计者)提供了对由用于拇指康复的特征组成或包含此类特征的机器人/机械设备当前技术水平的完整概述。此外,我们阐明了拇指的解剖学特征和运动,这些对于旨在支持其运动的任何设备的开发至关重要。希望这一点,结合概述的进一步研究机会,能带来当前设备的改进以及该领域新技术和知识的发展。