DiMarco Anthony F, Geertman Robert T, Tabbaa Kutaiba, Polito Rebecca R, Kowalski Krzysztof E
Department of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, Case Western Reserve University.
MetroHealth Research Institute, Case Western Reserve University.
Top Spinal Cord Inj Rehabil. 2017 Summer;23(3):271-278. doi: 10.1310/sci2303-271.
To determine if an implanted neuroprosthesis for restoration of an effective cough is less costly than conventional methods of respiratory management. Nonrandomized clinical trial of participants ( = 14) with spinal cord injury (SCI) using the Cough Stimulator device in the inpatient hospital setting for Cough Stimulator implantation and outpatient hospital or residence for follow-up. A neuroprosthesis was implanted for restoration of an effective cough. The annual costs associated with respiratory management, without (pre implantation) and with (post implantation) the neuroprosthesis, were examined over a 4-year period. The total cost related to implantation of the Cough Stimulator was $59,891, with no maintenance costs over subsequent years. The incidence of respiratory tract infections and the need for caregiver support fell significantly following implantation. The costs associated with respiratory tract infections fell significantly from a mean of $36,406 ± 11,855/year to $13,284 ± 7,035/year ( < .05) pre and post implantation, respectively. Costs fell further to $8,817 ± 5,990 and $4,467 ± 4,404 following the 2nd and 3rd years post implantation ( < .05), respectively. The costs associated with caregiver support fell significantly from $25,312 ± 8,019/year to $2,630 ± 2,233/year ( < .05) pre and post implantation, respectively, and remained low in subsequent years ( < .05). Other costs related to secretion management fell significantly and remained low in subsequent years ( < .05). Break-even analysis demonstrated that this point was reached in the first year. The results of this investigation demonstrate that implantation and use of the Cough Stimulator resulted in significant reductions in the overall costs of respiratory management in this patient population.
为确定用于恢复有效咳嗽的植入式神经假体是否比传统的呼吸管理方法成本更低。对14名脊髓损伤(SCI)患者进行非随机临床试验,在住院环境中使用咳嗽刺激器装置进行咳嗽刺激器植入,并在门诊或住所进行随访。植入神经假体以恢复有效咳嗽。在4年期间,检查了在没有(植入前)和有(植入后)神经假体的情况下与呼吸管理相关的年度成本。咳嗽刺激器植入的总成本为59,891美元,后续年份无维护成本。植入后呼吸道感染的发生率和对护理人员支持的需求显著下降。与呼吸道感染相关的成本从植入前的平均每年36,406±11,855美元显著降至植入后的13,284±7,035美元(P<.05)。植入后第2年和第3年,成本进一步降至8,817±5,990美元和4,467±4,404美元(P<.05)。与护理人员支持相关的成本从植入前的每年25,312±8,019美元显著降至植入后的2,630±2,233美元(P<.05),并且在随后几年中保持较低水平(P<.05)。与分泌物管理相关的其他成本显著下降,并且在随后几年中保持较低水平(P<.05)。盈亏平衡分析表明,这一点在第一年就达到了。这项调查的结果表明,咳嗽刺激器的植入和使用导致该患者群体呼吸管理的总体成本显著降低。