Poole Kristopher
Department of Archaeology, University of Nottingham, Humanities Building, University Park, Nottingham, NG7 2RD UK.
J Archaeol Method Theory. 2015;22(3):857-882. doi: 10.1007/s10816-014-9208-9. Epub 2014 Apr 24.
The growing popularity of relational approaches to agency amongst archaeologists has led to increased attention on the specific contexts of interaction between humans and their material worlds. Within such viewpoints, non-humans are perceived as agents in their own right and placed on an equal footing with humans, with both acting to generate social categories in past cultures. However, to date, the focus of these interpretative models has been overwhelmingly directed towards inanimate objects. Animals are generally absent from these discussions, despite their ubiquity in past societies and the frequently central roles they held within daily lives and social relations. Moreover, living animals are set apart from material culture because, like humans, they are usually aware of their environs and are capable of physically responding to them. This ability to 'act back' would have made human-animal interactions extremely dynamic and thus offers different conceptual challenges to archaeologists than when faced with objects. This paper demonstrates that the notion of performativity, combined with understanding of animals themselves, can help to comprehend these relations. It does so by focusing on one particular species, the domestic cat, in relation to Anglo-Saxon England. The characteristics and behaviour of these animals affected the ways in which humans perceived and interacted with them, so that just one individual cat could be categorised in a range of different ways. The classification of animals was thus just as fluid, if not more so, as that of objects and highlights the need to incorporate the former into reconstructions of the social in archaeological research.
关系论视角下的能动性在考古学家中日益流行,这使得人们越来越关注人类与其物质世界相互作用的具体背景。在这种观点中,非人类被视为具有自身能动性的主体,并与人类处于平等地位,二者共同作用于过去文化中社会范畴的形成。然而,迄今为止,这些解释模型的重点几乎都集中在无生命的物体上。尽管动物在过去社会中无处不在,且在日常生活和社会关系中常常扮演核心角色,但在这些讨论中它们却普遍缺席。此外,活体动物与物质文化有所不同,因为它们像人类一样,通常能感知周围环境并能做出身体反应。这种“反作用”的能力会使人类与动物的互动极具动态性,因此给考古学家带来了与面对物体时不同的概念挑战。本文表明,能动性概念与对动物本身的理解相结合,有助于理解这些关系。本文通过聚焦于一个特定物种——家猫,以及它与盎格鲁 - 撒克逊时期英格兰的关系来进行阐述。这些动物的特征和行为影响了人类对它们的认知方式以及与它们互动的方式,以至于仅一只猫就可以以多种不同方式被分类。因此,动物的分类即便不比物体的分类更具流动性,至少也是同样具有流动性的,这凸显了在考古研究中把动物纳入社会重建的必要性。