Faculty of Intensive Care Medicine Professional Standards, Nottingham University Hospitals, Nottingham, UK.
FICM Board (RCoEM), Manchester Royal Infirmary, Manchester, UK.
Br J Anaesth. 2018 Jan;120(1):138-145. doi: 10.1016/j.bja.2017.10.002. Epub 2017 Nov 23.
Patients with severe grades of life-threatening brain injury are commonly characterized as having devastating brain injury (DBI), which we have defined as: 'any neurological condition that is assessed at the time of hospital admission as an immediate threat to life or incompatible with good functional recovery AND where early limitation or withdrawal of therapy is being considered'. The outcome in patients with DBI is often death or severe disability, and as a consequence rapid withdrawal of life sustaining therapies is commonly contemplated or undertaken. However, accurate prognostication in life-threatening brain injury is difficult, particularly at an early stage. Evidence from controlled studies to guide decision-making is limited, and there is a risk of a 'self-fulfilling prophecy', with early prognostication leading to early withdrawal of life sustaining therapies and death. The Joint Professional Standards committee of the Faculty of Intensive Care Medicine and the Intensive Care Society convened a consensus group with representation from stakeholder professional organizations to develop clear professional guidance in this area. It recognized that the weak evidence base makes GRADE guidelines difficult to justify. We have made 12 practical, pragmatic recommendations to help clinicians deliver safe, effective, equitable, and justifiable care within resource constrained healthcare systems. In the situation where patient-centred outcomes are recognized to be unacceptable, regardless of the extent of neurological improvement, then early transition to palliative care is appropriate. These recommendations are intended to apply where the primary pathology is DBI, rather than where DBI has compounded a progressive and irreversible deterioration in other life-threatening comorbidities.
患有严重危及生命的脑损伤的患者通常被认为患有破坏性脑损伤(DBI),我们将其定义为:“任何在入院时被评估为对生命立即构成威胁或与良好功能恢复不相容的神经状况,并且正在考虑早期限制或停止治疗”。DBI 患者的结局通常是死亡或严重残疾,因此通常会考虑或进行快速停止维持生命的治疗。然而,危及生命的脑损伤的准确预后是困难的,特别是在早期阶段。指导决策的对照研究证据有限,并且存在“自我实现的预言”的风险,即早期预后导致早期停止维持生命的治疗和死亡。重症监护医学学院和重症监护学会的联合专业标准委员会召集了一个共识小组,代表利益相关者专业组织,在这一领域制定明确的专业指导意见。它认识到,证据基础薄弱使得 GRADE 指南难以证明其合理性。我们提出了 12 条实用的、务实的建议,以帮助临床医生在资源有限的医疗保健系统中提供安全、有效、公平和合理的护理。在患者为中心的结果被认为不可接受的情况下,无论神经功能改善程度如何,都应尽早过渡到姑息治疗。这些建议旨在适用于原发性病理为 DBI 的情况,而不是 DBI 加重其他危及生命的合并症的进行性和不可逆转恶化的情况。