Hajizade-Valokolaee Maryam, Khani Soghra, Fooladi Ensieh, Peivandi Sepideh
Student Research Committee, Department of Reproductive Health and Midwifery, School of Nursing and Midwifery, Mazandaran University of Medical Sciences, Sari, Iran.
Ph.D. of Reproductive Health, Assistant Professor, Sexual and Reproductive Health Research Center, Mazandaran University of Medical Sciences, Sari, Iran.
Electron Physician. 2017 Nov 25;9(11):5834-5843. doi: 10.19082/5834. eCollection 2017 Nov.
Infertility as a global problem, affects the different aspects of women's health. Also, violence against infertile women affects their psychological wellbeing and treatment consequence. This study aimed at reviewing related factors to violence against infertile women, based on an ecological approach.
In this systematic review, the researchers conducted their search in electronic databases such as Google Scholar, and then in more specialized ones such as Medline via PubMed, Science Direct, Up-to-date, Springer, SID, Magiran, Iranmedex and Irandoc with the key words violence, infertility, women, risk factors, social environment, and individuality, from 1988 to 2016. The selection of papers was undertaken from 20-27 January 2017. The articles were selected based on the following criteria: 1), the articles focused on the research question 2), infertility and violence were included in the title of the articles, and 3) articles were published in online journals. Exclusion criteria were articles which focused on violence against the general population, pregnant women and female sex workers and articles that were not available in full text form or written in other languages (Not Persian or English). The quality of selected studies was appraised using a 16-item checklist adapted from Tao. This checklist consisted of 16 items which used a 0 or 1 scoring system (not eligible or eligible). If an article received a score of 75% (12-16 points), it was of high quality. A score of 50% to 74% (8-12 points) indicated moderate quality, and less than 50% (8 points) indicated low quality. The process of titles, abstracts and full-texts' appraisal led to the selection of 16 articles, which were used to write this article.
Two of the articles based on 16-items of the check list had high quality score, 8 of them had moderate and the remaining articles had low quality score. Our findings were classified under three categories corresponding with the ecological approach: (1) Microsystem level "individual sociodemographic and infertility characteristics", (2) Mesosystem level "interpersonal' and husband sociodemographic characteristics" and (3) Macro system level considered ethnicity and cultural factors.
Violence against infertile women and the stress caused by it, would affect the consequences of infertility treatment. It is noted that various cultural-contextual factors cause violence in different societies. There is a need for the development of screening tools and applying counselors to identify infertile women at the risk of violence, and provide clinical services, counseling and social support.
不孕症作为一个全球性问题,影响着女性健康的各个方面。此外,针对不孕女性的暴力行为会影响她们的心理健康及治疗效果。本研究旨在基于生态方法,回顾与针对不孕女性的暴力行为相关的因素。
在这项系统评价中,研究人员先在谷歌学术等电子数据库中进行检索,然后在更为专业的数据库如通过PubMed的Medline、科学Direct、Up-to-date、施普林格、SID、Magiran、Iranmedex和Irandoc中进行检索,检索关键词为暴力、不孕、女性、危险因素、社会环境和个性,检索时间范围为1988年至2016年。论文筛选于2017年1月20日至27日进行。入选文章基于以下标准:1)文章聚焦于研究问题;2)文章标题中包含不孕和暴力;3)文章发表于在线期刊。排除标准为聚焦于针对普通人群、孕妇和女性性工作者的暴力行为的文章,以及无法获取全文或用其他语言(非波斯语或英语)撰写的文章。使用从陶氏改编的16项清单对所选研究的质量进行评估。该清单由16项组成,采用0或1评分系统(不符合或符合)。如果一篇文章得分达到75%(12 - 16分),则质量高。得分在50%至74%(8 - 12分)之间表示质量中等,低于50%(8分)表示质量低。通过对标题、摘要和全文的评估过程,最终选择了1篇文章用于撰写本文。
基于清单16项的文章中,有2篇质量得分高,8篇质量中等,其余文章质量得分低。我们的研究结果根据生态方法分为三类:(1)微观系统层面“个体社会人口学和不孕特征”;(2)中观系统层面“人际和丈夫社会人口学特征”;(3)宏观系统层面考虑种族和文化因素。
针对不孕女性的暴力行为及其造成的压力会影响不孕治疗的效果。需要注意的是,各种文化背景因素在不同社会中导致暴力行为。有必要开发筛查工具并应用咨询师来识别有暴力风险的不孕女性,并提供临床服务、咨询和社会支持。