College of Medicine, Qassim University, Qassim, PO Box: 6655, 51452, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.
Department of Computer and System Sciences (DSV), Stockholm University, Borgarfjordsgatan 12, PO Box 7003, SE-164 07, Kista, Sweden.
BMC Med Educ. 2018 Feb 6;18(1):24. doi: 10.1186/s12909-018-1126-1.
Collaborative learning facilitates reflection, diversifies understanding and stimulates skills of critical and higher-order thinking. Although the benefits of collaborative learning have long been recognized, it is still rarely studied by social network analysis (SNA) in medical education, and the relationship of parameters that can be obtained via SNA with students' performance remains largely unknown. The aim of this work was to assess the potential of SNA for studying online collaborative clinical case discussions in a medical course and to find out which activities correlate with better performance and help predict final grade or explain variance in performance.
Interaction data were extracted from the learning management system (LMS) forum module of the Surgery course in Qassim University, College of Medicine. The data were analyzed using social network analysis. The analysis included visual as well as a statistical analysis. Correlation with students' performance was calculated, and automatic linear regression was used to predict students' performance.
By using social network analysis, we were able to analyze a large number of interactions in online collaborative discussions and gain an overall insight of the course social structure, track the knowledge flow and the interaction patterns, as well as identify the active participants and the prominent discussion moderators. When augmented with calculated network parameters, SNA offered an accurate view of the course network, each user's position, and level of connectedness. Results from correlation coefficients, linear regression, and logistic regression indicated that a student's position and role in information relay in online case discussions, combined with the strength of that student's network (social capital), can be used as predictors of performance in relevant settings.
By using social network analysis, researchers can analyze the social structure of an online course and reveal important information about students' and teachers' interactions that can be valuable in guiding teachers, improve students' engagement, and contribute to learning analytics insights.
协作学习促进反思、多样化理解,并激发批判性和高阶思维技能。尽管协作学习的好处早已被认识到,但它在医学教育中的社会网络分析(SNA)研究中仍然很少被研究,并且通过 SNA 获得的参数与学生表现的关系在很大程度上仍然未知。本研究旨在评估 SNA 研究医学课程中在线协作临床病例讨论的潜力,并找出与更好表现相关的活动,帮助预测最终成绩或解释表现差异。
从沙特阿拉伯盖西姆大学医学院外科课程的学习管理系统(LMS)论坛模块中提取交互数据。使用社会网络分析对数据进行分析。分析包括可视化和统计分析。计算了与学生表现的相关性,并使用自动线性回归来预测学生的表现。
通过使用社会网络分析,我们能够分析在线协作讨论中的大量交互,并对课程的社会结构有一个整体的了解,跟踪知识流和交互模式,以及识别活跃的参与者和突出的讨论主持人。当与计算的网络参数结合使用时,SNA 提供了课程网络、每个用户的位置和连接水平的准确视图。相关系数、线性回归和逻辑回归的结果表明,学生在在线病例讨论中信息传递的位置和角色,以及该学生网络的强度(社会资本),可以作为相关环境中表现的预测因子。
通过使用社会网络分析,研究人员可以分析在线课程的社会结构,并揭示有关学生和教师交互的重要信息,这些信息对于指导教师、提高学生参与度和促进学习分析见解都很有价值。