Boyce Karen Stradford, Travers Madeline, Rothbart Betty, Santiago Vivian, Bedell Jane
1 New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, Bronx, NY, USA.
2 New York City Department of Education, New York, NY, USA.
Health Promot Pract. 2018 May;19(3):445-454. doi: 10.1177/1524839918756888. Epub 2018 Feb 7.
Lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender (LGBT) youth show higher rates of sexual risk behaviors than heterosexual and cisgender youth; yet, most school-based sexual health education is largely heteronormative and cisnormative and does not recognize the spectrum of sexual and gender identity. New York City's Departments of Health and Education collaborated to create an LGBT-inclusive supplement to the Reducing the Risk curriculum and implement it in 21 South Bronx high schools.
Teachers completed an electronic survey to report the number of students reached and an online log to measure curriculum adherence. Students were administered an anonymous 74-item pre- and posttest to measure demographics, sexual health knowledge, and student satisfaction with the curriculum. Chi-square and t tests were used to assess differences in student demographics and changes in knowledge scores.
Reducing the Risk was implemented in 21 schools reaching 230 classes and 5,673 students; with 161 classes receiving the supplement. Teachers reported completing an average of 70% of LGBT supplement activities. Students who received the supplement reported higher satisfaction and greater knowledge scores than students who did not.
New York City experience shows that being more inclusive of LGBT teens while implementing preexisting evidence-based sexual and reproductive health programs is possible and replicable.
女同性恋、男同性恋、双性恋和跨性别(LGBT)青少年比异性恋和顺性别青少年表现出更高的性风险行为发生率;然而,大多数基于学校的性健康教育在很大程度上是异性恋规范和顺性别规范的,并未认识到性取向和性别认同的多样性。纽约市卫生和教育部合作,为《降低风险》课程创建了一个包含LGBT内容的补充材料,并在南布朗克斯区的21所高中实施。
教师完成一项电子调查以报告覆盖的学生人数,并填写一份在线日志以衡量对课程的依从性。学生接受了一项包含74个条目的匿名前测和后测,以测量人口统计学特征、性健康知识以及学生对课程的满意度。使用卡方检验和t检验来评估学生人口统计学特征的差异以及知识得分的变化。
《降低风险》课程在21所学校实施,覆盖230个班级和5673名学生;其中161个班级接受了补充材料。教师报告平均完成了70%的LGBT补充活动。接受补充材料的学生比未接受的学生报告了更高的满意度和更高的知识得分。
纽约市的经验表明,在实施现有的循证性和生殖健康项目时,更包容LGBT青少年是可行且可推广的。