Institute of Health & Wellbeing, University of Glasgow, Glasgow, UK.
College of Social Science, University of Glasgow, Glasgow, UK.
J Intellect Disabil Res. 2018 Apr;62(4):349-357. doi: 10.1111/jir.12475. Epub 2018 Feb 9.
Adults with intellectual disabilities (IDs) have consistently poorer health outcomes than the general population. There is evidence that routine health checks in primary care may improve outcomes. We conducted a randomised controlled trial of practice nurse led health checks. Here, we report findings from the nested qualitative study.
To explore practice nurse perceptions and experience of delivering an anticipatory health check for adults with IDs.
Qualitative study in General Practices located in NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde, Scotland, UK.
Eleven practice nurses from 11 intervention practices participated in a semi-structured interview. Analysis was guided by a framework approach.
Practice nurses reported initially feeling 'swamped' and 'baffled' by the prospect of the intervention, but early misgivings were not realised. Health checks were incorporated into daily routines with relative ease, but this was largely contingent on existing patient engagement. The intervention was thought most successful with patients already well known to the practice. Chronic disease management models are commonly used by practice nurses and participants tailored health checks to existing practice. It emerged that few of the nurses utilised the breadth of the check instead modifying the check to respond to individual patients' needs. As such, already recognised 'problems' or issues dominated the health check process. Engaging with the health checks in this way appeared to increase the acceptability and feasibility of the check for nurses. There was universal support for the health check ethos, although some questioned whether all adults with IDs would access the health checks, and as a consequence, the long-term benefits of checks.
While the trial found the intervention to be dominant over standard health care, the adjustments nurses made may not have maximised potential benefits to patients. Increasing training could further improve the benefits that health checks provide for people with IDs.
成年智障人士(IDs)的健康状况始终劣于普通人群。有证据表明,初级保健中的常规健康检查可能会改善结果。我们对护士主导的健康检查进行了随机对照试验。在这里,我们报告嵌套定性研究的结果。
探索执业护士对为智障成年人提供预期健康检查的看法和经验。
在英国苏格兰 NHS 大格拉斯哥和克莱德的普通实践中进行的定性研究。
来自 11 个干预实践的 11 名执业护士参加了半结构化访谈。分析受框架方法的指导。
执业护士最初对干预措施的前景感到“不知所措”和“困惑”,但早期的疑虑并未实现。健康检查相对容易地融入了日常工作中,但这在很大程度上取决于现有患者的参与。该干预措施被认为在已熟悉该实践的患者中最成功。慢性病管理模式通常由执业护士使用,参与者根据现有实践调整健康检查。结果表明,很少有护士利用检查的广度,而是根据个别患者的需求修改检查。因此,已识别的“问题”或问题主导了健康检查过程。以这种方式参与健康检查似乎增加了护士对检查的可接受性和可行性。尽管有人质疑是否所有智障成年人都能接受健康检查,以及检查的长期益处,但对健康检查精神普遍持支持态度。
尽管试验发现干预措施优于标准保健,但护士所做的调整可能并未最大限度地提高患者的潜在收益。增加培训可以进一步提高健康检查为智障人士提供的收益。