Arthritis Research UK Primary Care Centre, Research Institute for Primary Care and Health Sciences, Keele University, UK.
West Midlands CLAHRC and South Staffs and Shropshire Foundation Trust, UK.
Res Synth Methods. 2018 Jun;9(2):273-284. doi: 10.1002/jrsm.1295. Epub 2018 Mar 12.
BACKGROUND & AIMS: Barriers to dissemination and engagement with evidence pose a threat to implementing evidence-based medicine. Understanding, retention, and recall can be enhanced by visual presentation of information. The aim of this exploratory research was to develop and evaluate the accessibility and acceptability of visual summaries for presenting evidence syntheses with multiple exposures or outcomes to professional and lay audiences.
"Evidence flowers" were developed as a visual method of presenting data from 4 case scenarios: 2 complex evidence syntheses with multiple outcomes, Cochrane reviews, and clinical guidelines. Petals of evidence flowers were coloured according to the GRADE evidence rating system to display key findings and recommendations from the evidence summaries. Application of evidence flowers was observed during stakeholder workshops. Evaluation and feedback were conducted via questionnaires and informal interviews.
Feedback from stakeholders on the evidence flowers collected from workshops, questionnaires, and interviews was encouraging and helpful for refining the design of the flowers. Comments were made on the content and design of the flowers, as well as the usability and potential for displaying different types of evidence.
Evidence flowers are a novel and visually stimulating method for presenting research evidence from evidence syntheses with multiple exposures or outcomes, Cochrane reviews, and clinical guidelines. To promote access and engagement with research evidence, evidence flowers may be used in conjunction with other evidence synthesis products, such as (lay) summaries, evidence inventories, rapid reviews, and clinical guidelines. Additional research on potential adaptations and applications of the evidence flowers may further bridge the gap between research evidence and clinical practice.
传播和参与证据的障碍对实施循证医学构成威胁。信息的可视化呈现可以提高理解、保留和回忆能力。本探索性研究旨在开发和评估视觉摘要在向专业和非专业受众呈现具有多种暴露或结局的证据综合时的可及性和可接受性。
“证据花”被开发为一种可视化方法,用于呈现来自 4 个案例场景的数据:2 个具有多种结局的复杂证据综合、Cochrane 综述和临床指南。证据花的花瓣根据 GRADE 证据评级系统着色,以显示证据综合的关键发现和建议。在利益相关者研讨会上观察证据花的应用。通过问卷和非正式访谈进行评估和反馈。
从研讨会、问卷和访谈中收集的利益相关者对证据花的反馈令人鼓舞,并有助于改进花朵的设计。对花朵的内容和设计以及可用性和展示不同类型证据的潜力提出了意见。
证据花是一种新颖的、视觉上令人兴奋的方法,用于呈现具有多种暴露或结局的证据综合、Cochrane 综述和临床指南的研究证据。为了促进研究证据的可及性和参与度,证据花可以与其他证据综合产品(如(非专业)摘要、证据清单、快速综述和临床指南)一起使用。对证据花的潜在改编和应用的进一步研究可能会进一步缩小研究证据与临床实践之间的差距。