H NMR-based metabolomics reveals interactive effects between the carrier solvent methanol and a pharmaceutical mixture in an amphibian developmental bioassay with Limnodynastes peronii.

Organic carrier solvents are used in aquatic toxicity testing to improve chemical solubility and facilitate the exploration of dose-response relationships. Both water- and solvent-control groups are normally included in these scenarios to ensure that the solvent itself has no effect on the test organism, but this fails to consider possible interactive effects between carrier solvents and contaminants of interest. We explored this topic by exposing Limnodynastes peronii tadpoles to a mixture of common water-soluble pharmaceuticals (diclofenac, metformin and valproic acid) in the presence and absence of the carrier solvent methanol, according to standard developmental bioassay methodology. Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) spectroscopy was applied as a platform for untargeted metabolomics, to compare broad sub-lethal hepatotoxicity in solvent- and solvent-free exposure scenarios. Considerable interactive effects were identified between the pharmaceutical mixture and a typical dose of methanol (0.003%). Specifically, pronounced differences were observed between the solvent- and solvent-free exposure groups for leucine, acetate, glutamine, citrate, glycogen, tyrosine, arginine, purine nucleotides and an unidentified metabolite at 6.53 ppm. Various other metabolites exhibited similar disparity related to the use of carrier solvent, but the interactions were non-significant. These results raise important questions about the use of carrier solvents for chemical exposures in aquatic ecotoxicology, and particularly for studies interested in sub-lethal mechanistic information and/or biomarker discovery.