Rasmussen Peter M, Secomb Timothy W, Pries Axel R
Department of Clinical Medicine, Center of Functionally Integrative Neuroscience, Aarhus University Hospital, Aarhus, Denmark.
Department of Physiology, University of Arizona, Tucson, AZ, USA.
Microcirculation. 2018 Apr;25(3):e12445. doi: 10.1111/micc.12445.
Theoretical models are essential tools for studying microcirculatory function. Recently, the validity of a well-established phase separation model was questioned and it was claimed that it produces problematically low hematocrit predictions and lack of red cells in small diameter vessels. We conducted a quantitative evaluation of this phase separation model to establish common ground for future research.
Model predictions were validated against a comprehensive database with measurements from 4 mesenteric networks. A Bayesian data analysis framework was used to integrate measurements and network model simulations into a combined analysis and to model uncertainties related to network boundary conditions as well as phase separation model parameters. The model evaluation was conducted within a cross-validation scheme.
Unlike the recently reported results, our analysis demonstrated good correspondence in global characteristics between measurements and predictions. In particular, predicted hematocrits for vessels with small diameters were consistent with measurements. Incorporating phase separation model parameter uncertainties further reduced the hematocrit validation error by 17% and led to the absence of red-cell-free segments. Corresponding model parameters are presented as alternatives to standard parameters.
Consistent with earlier studies, our quantitative model evaluation supports the continued use of the established phase separation model.
理论模型是研究微循环功能的重要工具。最近,一个成熟的相分离模型的有效性受到质疑,有人声称该模型会产生低得离谱的血细胞比容预测结果,并且在小直径血管中缺乏红细胞。我们对这个相分离模型进行了定量评估,为未来的研究奠定共同基础。
根据一个包含4个肠系膜网络测量数据的综合数据库对模型预测结果进行验证。使用贝叶斯数据分析框架将测量数据和网络模型模拟整合到一个联合分析中,并对与网络边界条件以及相分离模型参数相关的不确定性进行建模。模型评估是在交叉验证方案内进行的。
与最近报道的结果不同,我们的分析表明测量结果与预测结果在整体特征上具有良好的一致性。特别是,小直径血管的预测血细胞比容与测量结果一致。纳入相分离模型参数的不确定性进一步将血细胞比容验证误差降低了17%,并导致不存在无红细胞段。给出了相应的模型参数作为标准参数的替代方案。
与早期研究一致,我们的定量模型评估支持继续使用已建立的相分离模型。