Sacks S L, Portnoy J, Lawee D, Schlech W, Aoki F Y, Tyrrell D L, Poisson M, Bright C, Kaluski J
J Infect Dis. 1987 Feb;155(2):178-86. doi: 10.1093/infdis/155.2.178.
Clinic-initiated topical treatment of recurrent genital herpes with foscarnet cream (concentration, 0.3% in men and 1% in women) was compared with a placebo in a Canadian multicenter trial involving 309 patients. Culture-positive episodes of herpes took significantly longer to heal than did the others. Lesions in men were larger and lasted longer but were less symptomatic than those in women. Foscarnet did not statistically improve the times to healing or the loss of symptoms overall but did result in a higher proportion of symptom-free individuals after one day of treatment. Foscarnet-treated patients had a reduced duration of shedding of virus, and this was significant for men. These clinical benefits do not, however, warrant general use of this agent for established lesions. Earlier, prodromal treatment might have been more effective, but patient-initiated studies include a greater proportion of culture-negative (shorter) episodes that often make results difficult to interpret.
在一项涉及309名患者的加拿大多中心试验中,将膦甲酸钠乳膏(男性浓度为0.3%,女性浓度为1%)对复发性生殖器疱疹进行临床起始的局部治疗与安慰剂进行了比较。疱疹培养阳性发作的愈合时间明显长于其他发作。男性的病损更大、持续时间更长,但症状比女性轻。膦甲酸钠在统计学上并没有改善总体愈合时间或症状消失情况,但在治疗一天后确实导致无症状个体的比例更高。接受膦甲酸钠治疗的患者病毒脱落持续时间缩短,这对男性而言具有显著意义。然而,这些临床益处并不足以证明该药物可普遍用于已出现的病损。早期进行前驱期治疗可能会更有效,但患者自行发起的研究中培养阴性(病程较短)发作的比例更高,这常常使结果难以解释。