Pharmaceutical Care Research Group, Department of Pharmaceutical Sciences, University of Basel, Basel, Switzerland.
Institute of Hospital Pharmacy, Solothurner Spitäler, Olten, Switzerland.
BMJ Open. 2018 Mar 9;8(3):e016610. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2017-016610.
Identifying patients with a high risk for drug-related problems (DRPs) might optimise the allocation of targeted pharmaceutical care during the hospital stay and on discharge.
To develop a self-assessment screening tool to identify patients at risk for DRPs and validate the tool regarding feasibility, acceptability and the reliability of the patients' answers.
Prospective validation study.
Two mid-sized hospitals (300-400 beds).
195 patients, exclusion criteria: under 18 years old, patients with a health status not allowing a meaningful communication (eg, delirium, acute psychosis, advanced dementia, aphasia, clouded consciousness state), palliative or terminally ill patients.
Twenty-seven risk factors for the development of DRPs, identified in a previous study, provided the basis of the self-assessment questionnaire, the Drug-Associated Risk Tool (DART). Consenting patients filled in DART, and we compared their answers with objective patient data from medical records and laboratory data.
One hundred and sixty-four patients filled in DART V.1.0 in an average time of 7 min. After a first validation, we identified statements with a low sensitivity and revised the wording of the questions related to heart insufficiency, renal impairment or liver impairment. The revised DART (V.2.0) was validated in 31 patients presenting heart insufficiency, renal impairment or liver impairment as comorbidity and reached an average specificity of 88% (range 27-100) and an average sensitivity of 67% (range 21-100).
DART showed a satisfying feasibility and reliability. The specificity of the statements was mostly high. The sensitivity varied and was higher in statements concerning diseases that require regular disease control and attention to self-care and drug management. Asking patients about their conditions, medications and related problems can facilitate getting a first, broad picture of the risk for DRPs and possible pharmaceutical needs.
识别出存在药物相关问题(DRP)风险的患者,可能会优化住院和出院期间目标药物治疗的分配。
开发一种自我评估筛查工具,以识别有 DRP 风险的患者,并验证该工具在可行性、可接受性以及患者答案的可靠性方面的效果。
前瞻性验证研究。
两家中型医院(300-400 张床位)。
195 名患者,排除标准:年龄在 18 岁以下、健康状况不允许进行有意义的沟通(如谵妄、急性精神病、晚期痴呆、失语、意识模糊状态)、姑息治疗或终末期患者。
在之前的研究中确定了 27 个与 DRP 发生相关的风险因素,这些因素为自我评估问卷——药物相关风险工具(DART)提供了基础。同意参与的患者填写 DART,并将他们的答案与病历中的客观患者数据和实验室数据进行比较。
164 名患者平均用时 7 分钟填写了 DART V.1.0。经过首次验证,我们确定了一些敏感性较低的陈述,并修改了与心功能不全、肾功能损害或肝功能损害相关的问题措辞。修订后的 DART(V.2.0)在 31 名患有心功能不全、肾功能损害或肝功能损害合并症的患者中进行了验证,平均特异性为 88%(范围为 27%-100%),平均敏感性为 67%(范围为 21%-100%)。
DART 表现出令人满意的可行性和可靠性。陈述的特异性大多较高。敏感性有所不同,在涉及需要定期疾病控制和关注自我护理及药物管理的疾病的陈述中更高。询问患者有关他们的病情、药物和相关问题,可以帮助我们初步了解 DRP 风险和可能的药物治疗需求。