Department of Psychiatry,McGill University,Douglas Mental Health University Institute; Prevention and Early Intervention Program for Psychosis (PEPP-Montreal),Montreal,QC,Canada.
McGill University,Douglas Hospital Research Centre,Montreal,QC,Canada.
Psychol Med. 2019 Jan;49(1):66-74. doi: 10.1017/S003329171800048X. Epub 2018 Mar 14.
Specialized early intervention (EI) following a first episode of psychosis (FEP) are effective at reducing negative symptoms, although its trajectory warrants systematic assessment. However, findings are equivocal as to whether extended gains are made post 2 years of EI and whether there is additional benefit of extending EI for an additional 3 years.
Data on 178 FEP patients, from a randomized controlled trial of a 3-year extension of EI service v. transfer to regular care following 2 years of EI service, were used for this report. Repeated measures analysis of variance were conducted separately for the initial 2 years of treatment in an EI service, and for the 3-year post-randomization to examine trajectories of negative symptoms over the two periods in the two arms of the study.
There were significant improvements in total negative symptoms over the first 2 years of EI F(4.612, 797.905) = 25.263, p < 0.001 and in domains of 'expressivity' and 'motivation'. In the following 3 years, there were further significant improvements in negative symptoms F(4.318, 759.908) = 4.182, p = 0.002 with no difference between groups F(4.318, 759.908) = 1.073, p = 0.371. Changes in negative symptoms over the extension period were driven by expressivity F(4.01, 674.73) = 7.19, p < 0.01, but not motivation F(6.58, 1112.18) = 0.95, p = 0.46.
Negative symptoms improve significantly over the first 2 years of EI. Subsequent amelioration was largely the result of expressivity. Motivation deficits remained stable. Extended EI offered no advantage over regular care post-randomization.
在首次精神病发作(FEP)后进行专门的早期干预(EI)可以有效减轻阴性症状,尽管其轨迹需要系统评估。然而,关于是否在 EI 后 2 年还能获得额外的长期收益,以及是否额外延长 EI 治疗 3 年是否会有额外的获益,研究结果尚无定论。
本报告使用了一项为期 3 年的 EI 服务扩展随机对照试验的数据,比较了 EI 服务延长 3 年与 EI 服务 2 年后转常规护理对 178 例 FEP 患者的疗效。分别对 EI 服务治疗的最初 2 年和随机分组后 3 年进行重复测量方差分析,以检查研究两个臂的两个时期的阴性症状轨迹。
EI 治疗的前 2 年,阴性症状的总分(F(4.612, 797.905) = 25.263,p < 0.001)和“表达”和“动机”两个领域都有显著改善。在随后的 3 年中,阴性症状进一步显著改善(F(4.318, 759.908) = 4.182,p = 0.002),两组之间没有差异(F(4.318, 759.908) = 1.073,p = 0.371)。延长治疗期间阴性症状的变化是由表达驱动的(F(4.01, 674.73) = 7.19,p < 0.01),但动机没有变化(F(6.58, 1112.18) = 0.95,p = 0.46)。
EI 治疗的前 2 年,阴性症状显著改善。随后的改善主要是表达的结果。动机缺陷保持稳定。随机分组后,延长 EI 治疗与常规护理相比没有优势。