Liu A N
J Med Ethics. 1987 Jun;13(2):69-73. doi: 10.1136/jme.13.2.69.
The author considers that some of the reasonings used by both the American and English courts against recognising a wrongful life claim are far from persuasive. However, there may indeed be strong public policy reasons against judicial recognition of such a claim. If judicial remedy is not possible for children in wrongful life situations, society ought to assist them in the alleviation of some of the practical problems caused by deformities.
作者认为，美国和英国法院用以反对承认错误生命索赔的一些推理远没有说服力。然而，确实可能存在强有力的公共政策理由来反对司法上承认此类索赔。如果对于处于错误生命情形中的儿童无法提供司法救济，社会应当帮助他们缓解由残疾所导致的一些实际问题。
