Stefanati Armando, Brosio Federica, Kuhdari Parvanè, Baccello Valeria, De Paris Paola, Nardini Marco, Boschetto Piera, Lupi Silvia, Gabutti Giovanni
Dipartimento di Scienze Mediche, Università degli Studi di Ferrara, Italia.
Dipartimento Interaziendale di Prevenzione e Protezione, Azienda Ospedaliero-Universitaria, Arcispedale S.Anna, Ferrara, Italia.
Ig Sanita Pubbl. 2017 Nov-Dec;73(6):633-648.
The hospital as a work environment is particularly characterized by various risks for healthcare workers (HCWs). The main risk is represented by biological accidents, associated with the parenteral transmission of pathogens. Biological injuries can occur during the care service and the manipulation of biological fluids. Hepatitis B (and hepatitis D), hepatitis C and HIV are the most common infections transmitted by biological injuries. Physicians should acquire awareness of the risks associated with their professional activity during their training as medical residents (MRs). Some infectious diseases are preventable by vaccination and the "National Immunization Plan 2017-2019" (PNPV) recommends HCWs vaccination against hepatitis B, influenza, measles -mumps -rubella, chicken pox, and pertussis. Besides, not only HCWs' vaccination can prevent the disease in healthcare professionals, but it also may reduce the transmission to patients. Therefore, active immunization of HCWs by recommended vaccinations plays an important role to prevent disease cases, complications and death in patients. An increased awareness of risk behaviors is the first important point to address in order to reduce biological accidents and infectious diseases transmission, so as to reduce their frequency. Besides, HCWs' vaccination is useful to reinforce protection and to prevent the transmission of some infectious diseases in case of exposure. The aim of this five-year incidence study is to investigate the MRs' biological accidents characteristics and to analyze the MRs' immune status at the University of Ferrara in the period 2011-2015. Data on MRs' biological accidents and immune status at Azienda Ospedaliero-Universitaria of Ferrara in 2011-2015 were analyzed by Microsoft Excel 2007 Software. In this study, the percentage of MRs' biological injuries compared to the total number of MRs showed an annual variability, with a peak in 2011 (11.9%). During the analyzed period, there were 190 biological injuries among the MRs: 81% were percutaneous injuries and blood was the biological fluid involved in 86.3% of cases. The most frequent lesion was puncture (62.6%), occurred in 41.1% of cases by suture needles; 46.3% of accidents occurred in the operating block. These data can be explained by the more invasive and at risk activities carried out in these Operative Units. The high injuries percentage in MRs may be related to less work experience and inadequate training or informations about personal protective equipment use. Among MRs, 93.7%, 93.3% and 96.6% were immune to measles, chicken pox and hepatitis B, respectively; only in the case of rubella, 11.9% of MRs was not immune. This research showed, accordingly to published data, high adhesion to hepatitis B vaccination. However, the healthcare workers' vaccine coverage is still sub-optimal; active immunization by recommended vaccines should be implemented for both parenteral and airborne diseases. As a matter of fact, the recent measles outbreak has involved healthcare workers (4689 cases of measles, 305 in HCWs). Finally, the General Directorates of Health-care settings should improve healthcare personnel adhesion to vaccinations, such as influenza, by promotion activities in the workplace. A proposal in order to achieve coverage objectives could be making vaccinations mandatory, as well as already implemented in other countries.
医院作为一个工作环境,医护人员面临着各种特殊风险。主要风险是生物事故,与病原体的非肠道传播有关。生物伤害可能发生在护理服务和生物液体的处理过程中。乙型肝炎(和丁型肝炎)、丙型肝炎和艾滋病毒是生物伤害传播的最常见感染。医生在住院医师培训期间就应该认识到与其职业活动相关的风险。一些传染病可通过接种疫苗预防,《2017 - 2019年国家免疫计划》(PNPV)建议医护人员接种乙型肝炎、流感、麻疹 - 腮腺炎 - 风疹、水痘和百日咳疫苗。此外,医护人员接种疫苗不仅可以预防医护人员患病,还可能减少向患者的传播。因此,通过推荐疫苗对医护人员进行主动免疫对于预防患者的疾病病例、并发症和死亡起着重要作用。提高对风险行为的认识是减少生物事故和传染病传播以降低其发生频率的首要重点。此外,医护人员接种疫苗有助于加强防护,并在接触情况下预防某些传染病的传播。这项为期五年的发病率研究旨在调查费拉拉大学2011 - 2015年期间住院医师的生物事故特征,并分析他们的免疫状况。2011 - 2015年费拉拉大学医院住院医师的生物事故和免疫状况数据通过Microsoft Excel 2007软件进行分析。在本研究中,住院医师生物伤害占住院医师总数的百分比呈现年度变化,2011年达到峰值(11.9%)。在分析期间,住院医师中有190起生物伤害事件:81%为经皮损伤,86.3%的病例涉及血液作为生物液体。最常见的损伤是穿刺(62.6%),41.1%的病例由缝合针导致;46.3%的事故发生在手术区。这些数据可以通过这些手术科室进行的侵入性更强且风险更高的活动来解释。住院医师中高伤害率可能与工作经验较少、培训不足或关于个人防护设备使用的信息不足有关。在住院医师中,分别有93.7%、93.3%和96.6%对麻疹、水痘和乙型肝炎免疫;仅风疹方面,11.9%的住院医师未免疫。这项研究表明,与已发表的数据一致,对乙型肝炎疫苗的接种依从性较高。然而,医护人员的疫苗接种覆盖率仍未达到最佳水平;对于非肠道传播和空气传播疾病,都应通过推荐疫苗进行主动免疫。事实上,最近的麻疹疫情涉及了医护人员(4689例麻疹病例,其中305例为医护人员)。最后,医疗机构的总卫生局应通过工作场所的推广活动提高医护人员对流感等疫苗接种的依从性。为实现覆盖目标,可以像其他国家已经实施的那样,将疫苗接种规定为强制性的。